ipod or se 810i???

dtox · 08-04-2007, 05:22 PM

ok.. this is a wierd query.. i cant decide whether to buy an ipod 30 gb or se 810i..
i need a good music player and a phone as well.. i currently own an n-gage qd which is an antique piece now as its no longer available in the market! so wat do u guys say?? shd i spend 11k on ipod and continue wit my ngage qd or shd i get 810i for 13k n screw the pod?? need i remind u tht i am a big music freak!!

blueshift · 08-04-2007, 05:36 PM

How can u compre iPod and 810i which is also a mobile?

Buy an iPhone instead.

dtox · 08-04-2007, 06:34 PM

thats wat i wanna kno.. do i continue wit my ngage n get a new ipod or shd i get 810i?? coz my primary usage is music.. n i saw in a thread in "fight club" section tht audio quality of both is same.. so if i buy 810i, i get mp3 player as well as a phone.. so is it worth it?? or shd i continue wit my ngage n wait for some better phone to come along and make do with an ipod for now coz my ngage is barely a year old

2kewl · 08-04-2007, 06:36 PM

Weird comparison but I'd say W810i

08-04-2007, 06:48 PM

Buy w810 with

dtox · 08-04-2007, 07:46 PM

cool post k750!!!

hw much for the above accesories

Quote:

Originally Posted by blueshift

How can u compre iPod and 810i which is also a mobile?

Buy an iPhone instead.

iphone is like a year away n waaaaaayyyyyy outta my budget!

Rockstar11 · 09-04-2007, 05:54 PM

hmm...
music + camera = Sony W810i

sagsall4u · 09-04-2007, 09:39 PM

the quality of music on d SE phone is better than the ipod (tried and tested).
i wud say definitely the SE810i with or without the accessories

Crazy Kidd · 10-04-2007, 01:12 PM

iPOD vs W810i.

The price is not comparable.

Not to mention they are in diff. league. My choice buy a W900i.

desh2s · 10-04-2007, 02:47 PM

go for ipod...

koolbluez · 10-04-2007, 03:55 PM

SE W810i.. why doubt...
With the SE W810i... u get the ipod (ok..ok.. it's a walkman)... a 2megapx digital camera with au5tofocus & macro(and yes... video rec..poor though)... a kool looking phone...
With the ipod.. u get a ipod

Thats all...

infra_red_dude · 10-04-2007, 04:21 PM

+1 for w810i. go for it. u wont regret! [

]

dtox · 10-04-2007, 04:41 PM

yup.. u guys hav convinced me.. goin for 810i now.. thanks ppl!!

btw infra_red_dude, tht smiley inside the bracket thing works only in orkut!! he he

Pathik · 10-04-2007, 05:29 PM

get the ipod... and keep ur ngage... u ll hav the best of mobile games and music too then..

infra_red_dude · 10-04-2007, 05:35 PM

^^^ but surely carrying both wud be cumbersome. consider the advantages: great music player, phone, 2mp cam wid autofocus, fm player... everything in a single package!

@dtox....

hehe... yeah buddy.. had an orkut window open by the side!

sivarap · 10-04-2007, 06:21 PM

There are great games for 810 also....I'd suggest u go for W830

(How do i add a pic in the post

)

dtox · 10-04-2007, 10:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sivarap

There are great games for 810 also....I'd suggest u go for W830

(How do i add a pic in the post

)

yeah.. but they wont b as good as ngage games.. 810i supports only java games..and i agree wit infra_red_dude bout the bulky nature of ipod n ngage combined.. 810i sounds tempting in that area.. also r their ne new fones comin up that will b as good as or even better than 810i for 14k in the near future?? by near i mean 1-2 months.. coz my ngage resale value is dropping n i need to get rid of it sooner rather than later..

hw much does 830 cost neway?? also for 14k, wil i get a better fone than 810i??

Quote:

Originally Posted by pathiks

get the ipod... and keep ur ngage... u ll hav the best of mobile games and music too then..

]

yeah.. but in case u havent heard, ngage games r no more being made.. they r done wit it..

thats one of the reason i want to get rid of it..

infra_red_dude · 10-04-2007, 10:25 PM

hmmm... u mite wanna wait for w580i. it shud cost abt 16k. not sure tho. but for 14k, w810i is the best deal, tho its sometime now that the phone's been around.

Pathik · 10-04-2007, 11:24 PM

there are 62 original ngage games.. Hav u played all

?? Btw w810i is out of production now.. Perhaps.. So wait for the w580i.. Its a beauty

moshel · 10-04-2007, 11:27 PM

if i were in ur place i wud go for ipod...primary reason the battery......i myself own W550i but dont use it much for music, cos when i do, it eats the battery like hell, and then u never knw when u m8 need the phone the most......and the battery wud run out....this is just my point of view.

thats why i hav separately bought a ipod 1gb solely for music.although the one i got is a "miniature" one....30gb wud be big....so u m8 be in a fix abt how to carry abt both things in this case...think over it...

dtox · 11-04-2007, 12:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pathiks

there are 62 original ngage games.. Hav u played all

?? Btw w810i is out of production now.. Perhaps.. So wait for the w580i.. Its a beauty

played most.. dare i say i downloaded them from the net, installed on phone n completed em... i have mostly all the latest ngage games.. u name it!! now i want more!!!!

n i don think 810i is outta production..is it???

Quote:

Originally Posted by moshel

thats why i hav separately bought a ipod 1gb solely for music.although the one i got is a "miniature" one....30gb wud be big....so u m8 be in a fix abt how to carry abt both things in this case...think over it...

yeah mate..i am thinkin over it.. thts wat tilts the balance towards 810i..

and just outta curiosity, is the audio quality of 550i better than 810i??

infra_red_dude · 11-04-2007, 11:19 AM

well if audio's played thru the onboard speakers, then yes. w550i has an edge over w810i (stereo speakers, widening...) but thru the headset, its the same....

dtox · 11-04-2007, 03:18 PM

but isint 550i less expensive than 810i?? logically 810i 's audio shd b better.. n wat r ur views on 710i??

2kewl · 11-04-2007, 03:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dtox

but isint 550i less expensive than 810i?? logically 810i 's audio shd b better.. n wat r ur views on 710i??

it is bett..Just that W550i is loud. And dont go for W550, its got 256 MB limited memory, Shitty cam.

W810i is better and if you want you can pick a new model in W610i.

It has all the features of 810i + lighter+ Walkman Player 2.0

dtox · 11-04-2007, 04:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 2kewl

it is bett..Just that W550i is loud. And dont go for W550, its got 256 MB limited memory, Shitty cam.

W810i is better and if you want you can pick a new model in W610i.

It has all the features of 810i + lighter+ Walkman Player 2.0

hw much is it for?? btw its review at gsmarena arent as good as 810i

http://www.gsmarena.com/sony_ericsson_w610-1845.php

so 810i or 610i?? which has a better sound quality n speaker?

supernova · 11-04-2007, 05:13 PM

How bout u save a lotta money

by sticking to ur Ngage and getting ipod shuffle 1 gb... (you'll anyways get default 512 MB of music on 810i)

dtox · 11-04-2007, 05:22 PM

@supernova

well.. theres a thought!! nicely put.. oughta think on tht!

jamyang312 · 11-04-2007, 05:24 PM

go for the phone,,,,u get speakers tooo along wid f.m.,,,,plus a great camera too,,,its a nice phone,,,howeva,,,for showing off,,,i pod is good,,but then ,,even the SE is good there,,,make sure u buy an external speaker accessory too,,,that will be a good pair,,

dtox · 11-04-2007, 05:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jamyang312

go for the phone,,,,u get speakers tooo along wid f.m.,,,,plus a great camera too,,,its a nice phone,,,howeva,,,for showing off,,,i pod is good,,but then ,,even the SE is good there,,,make sure u buy an external speaker accessory too,,,that will be a good pair,,

hw much for the se accessory??

will my ngage memory card work in 810i?? its a small memory card 256 mb (ncp)