which two phones?

[amitbhawani]

I have an total budget of 17k for two phones.

Criteria for first phone-
Should be an android touchscreen phones with 3g, gps and Wi-Fi, a physical QWERTY keyboard (useful but to mandatory)

My Considerations-
Samsung Galaxy 551
LG Optimus One
Spice mi310

Second Phone-
Should be have an QWERT keyboard, Wi-Fi, (3G an advantage but not mandatory)

My Considerations-
Nokia E63
Samsung Chat 335

Please help me out guys i am in real confusion... cant decide....

[desiibond]

LG Optimus One and Nokia E5.

[vishurocks]

Yup. Lg o1 and nokia e5

[amitbhawani]

but the E5 and O1 combo exceeds my budget, doesnt it??

[NainO]

LG Optimus One and Nokia C3.
If you can increase your budget you can replace C3 with above suggested phone i.e. E5.

[amitbhawani]

Nokia C3-
No 3G only Wi-Fi
Symbian S40

E63-
3G and Wi-Fi
Symbian S60

why the C3 and not the E63??

[vishurocks]

If u can extend ur budget by 2k. I.e. 19k. U could lgo1+e5

[Soumik]

^^ same suggestion from my side.
If your spending 17K, try a bit to extend to 19K and get lgO1 and E5.

[amitbhawani]

I can extend the budget. but can u guys tell me as to why shud i choose the E5 over E63 ??

[Sam]

E63:
3G: Yes, 384 kbps. good enough reason?

PS: copied from GSMArena.

[amitbhawani]

E63 basically doesnt have HSDPA with 3G.
but my doubt is is it really worth for the Indian 3G networks??