New Amd Rig

[sagsall4u]

hey guys . comment on this.

procc - amd 5000+ - 8000
mobo - Asus M2A-VM - 5100
Ram - kingston/transcend 1gb @ 667mhz - 2100
Hdisk - seagate / hitachi sata 2 160gb - 2500
DVD rw- Liteon LH20A1P - 1800
Monitor - viewsonic 17" LCD - 8800
cabinet + smps - any1 - 2000
speakers - APT 3 - 2800
TOTAL -- 36 grand..(prices sourced from theitwares.com )
Pls give your suggestions and comments on d abv rig.

[vish786]

macha u missed d graphics card

[gauravakaasid]

no gfx card?

@vish786...u beat me to it!!

[abhi1301]

Wat bout kabd & more IMP MOUSE ??????? will u buy the very normal stuff or lookin for a good mouse ??

[vish786]

Originally Posted by abhi1301

Wat bout kabd & more IMP MOUSE ??????? will u buy the very normal stuff or lookin for a good mouse ??

why to simply waste more money on keyboard and mouse... instead by something extra.... i suggest

[keith_j_snyder2]

nice HTPC config.

Is it ur Motherboard is HDMI enabled?

[rahul30]

the price difference between amd x2 4800 and amd x2 5000 is not justified....if ur going for x2 5200 @ 8k then please go for x2 5200+ arnd 8.5k (u will get 2 mb cache memory) or else go for x2 4800 for arnd 6.5k and save the 1.5k and invest on smps or some other stuff...if u still wanna go for x2 5000 then go for x2 5200 for only 500 rs extra...

b.t.w i am buying my pc tom: see wat i m buying

1) amd x2 4800 = 6500
2) biostar amd 690g= 4200
3) 1 gb ddr2 667 mhz= 2500 (price offered to me in kolkata
4) 160 gb hard disk - 2500
5) cabinet+smps- 3000 (invest on a good spmps as it will help in long run)

total comes to arnd 18700 and with 4% vat comes to arnd 19500!

now compare this with intel config:
1) intel core 2 duo E6420 - 10000
2) msi neo f- 5700
3) 1 gb ddr2 667 mhz= 2500 (price offered to me in kolkata
4) 160 gb hard disk - 2500
5) cabinet+smps- 3000 (invest on a good spmps as it will help in long run)
6) graphics card- appx 2000 (coz the mobo doesnt come with integrated gfx)

total - 25700 and and with 4%vat it comes to 26800 appx

now to compare the two the difference in price is roughly 7500 rs ...which is not justified if you are going to use it moderately for home in day to day life...also it was said by anandtech that E6400 was between amd 4600 and amd 5000 in performance so i dont think u will miss out on a huge deal for the given price...this is when u dont overclock i.e comparison at stock speed...
so decide which config is more sensible for guyz with a budget!

[premsharma]

@rahul30 a great reasoning. Your AMD configuration is very nice and very competitive price. Intel systems are useless considering their price. More over with this Biostar [AMD 690G] motherbaord you will get onboard graphics i.e. ATI X1200 which is best at present in integrated graphics catagory. Also at present biostar board is best among all when compared with Asus & MSI etc because it has both DVI as well as HDMI integrated. One more thing if you want to look is you should go for 65nm processor instead of 90nm

[rahul30]

Originally Posted by premsharma

@rahul30 a great reasoning. Your AMD configuration is very nice and very competitive price. Intel systems are useless considering their price. More over with this Biostar [AMD 690G] motherbaord you will get onboard graphics i.e. ATI X1200 which is best at present in integrated graphics catagory. Also at present biostar board is best among all when compared with Asus & MSI etc because it has both DVI as well as HDMI integrated. One more thing if you want to look is you should go for 65nm processor instead of 90nm

yes buddy 65nm processor will be better choice (there is not extra price for 65nm)....b.t.w prem- which system did u ultimately buy??? i am buying my amd rig tom

[premsharma]

I could not buy yet as I am under relocation [shifting]. Will buy soon. I have already narrowed down to 5000+, 5200+ or 5600+ with 690G mobo, presently inclined towards Biostar, or I will wait for ATX 690G from Asus/MSI.

[rahul30]

buddy i went to the market today and these are the prices i got

1) amd x2 4800- rs 6175
amd x2 5200- rs 8450

2) biostar motherboard 690g (that guy said its sli and i dont think its possible)- rs. 5000

3) 1 gb ddr2 667 mhz ram- 2450
4)160gb hard disk sata- 2400

except for the motherboard i suppose everything is fixed...i m not really getting one point that this dealer is claiming that it is an atx motherboard sli with amd 690g...i have'nt found this anywhere in any websites??? u got any idea?

[keith_j_snyder2]

^^ well tell him to show the perky thing!!!
And do tell us afterwards

[rahul30]

Originally Posted by keith_j_snyder2

^^ well tell him to show the perky thing!!!
And do tell us afterwards

finally i bought the following rig:

1) amd x2 5200 (65nm tdp)- 8550
2) asus m2a-vm - 4100
3) 1 gb ddr2 ram 667 mhz - 2500 (kingston)
4) 160 gb hard disk - 2250
5) navtech cabinet - 1900 (with 500w smps)

total 19300 and after tax 20000/-

[cynosure]

^^You got this from Delhi?

I think that coz of the 4%VAT but still!!

[rahul30]

Originally Posted by cynosure

^^You got this from Delhi?

I think that coz of the 4%VAT but still!!

no dude...got this in kolkata!

[magnet]

i dont know why u ppl prefer amd when u shelving above 10k on mobo cpu.....

e4300 best stuff to buy if u have that much money...

i myself got an amd one today.....

amd 3600+ and jetway board...but will oc it to use at speed of 4600+ processer....i jus spended 6.8k on both...if htpc is the reason.. than its fine....

btw u wont find biostar board now...they have gone all nvidia now and jus 1-2 days bak they released one board...so i guess by end of the month ull get one but with nvidia chipset

[cynosure]

Waise guys I thougt bout this config which I am going to buy maybe next month. Post your comments::

AMD Athlon 64 X2 5400+
Asus M2AVM-HDMI
2x2/1x4 GB 667MHz RAM (Going for a 64bit Linux)
Seagate 320GB SATA II HDD
Lite-On LH-20A1P DVD burner
Benq 17 '' FP71G LCD VDU
Any 2.1 speaker system (creative most prob.)
Logitech Keybord+mouse combo
APC 1KVA/800VA UPS
Cabinet with 600W PSU.

Waiting for Gfx card when ATI launches their products.
Maybe after 2 months the prices of cards will fall, then Ill think of buying one
tab tak onboard gfx zindabaad!!!
I have my eyes on the 8800GT 640MB card but hope ATI will come with something better and cheaper.

[rahul30]

actually ppl have a very wrong perception of core 2 duo being better than everything else...yes i agree that it is a new architecture but nowhere u can question amd because trust me in day to day browsing u wont even able to tell me the difference between the two...also every1 is not born with a lavish budget to spend...had i gone for the core 2 duo quivalent of amd x2 5200 i.e E6420 i would have paid 10000 for the processor and another 5800 for the motherboard and another 2k for a very low end graphics card...and that makes no sense... amd 690g integrated gfx is the best available right now as then combo which i got for 12500 u can compare with E6420 & mobo for arnd 16000 (also add 2k for gpu)+2k= 18k...now tell me wts da diff...and for your info i dont overclock srry not for me!

Originally Posted by cynosure

Waise guys I thougt bout this config which I am going to buy maybe next month. Post your comments::

AMD Athlon 64 X2 5400+
Asus M2AVM-HDMI
2x2/1x4 GB 667MHz RAM (Going for a 64bit Linux)
Seagate 320GB SATA II HDD
Lite-On LH-20A1P DVD burner
Benq 17 '' FP71G LCD VDU
Any 2.1 speaker system (creative most prob.)
Logitech Keybord+mouse combo
APC 1KVA/800VA UPS
Cabinet with 600W PSU.

Waiting for Gfx card when ATI launches their products.
Maybe after 2 months the prices of cards will fall, then Ill think of buying one
tab tak onboard gfx zindabaad!!!
I have my eyes on the 8800GT 640MB card but hope ATI will come with something better and cheaper.

buddy if u can wait for a month or two...u can get the quad core arnd 12k range...i wanted to go for that but i had to buy a pc so din have ne option...if u can wait just hold on for a month or so..

[cynosure]

^^Quad core will be a dream for me.
I mean here for 15k I get both mobo and proc. but then I cud only get a pro.
waise you are talking bout intel or amd???

You are making me to google about the quad core market.
Thanks anyway!!!

[rahul30]

Originally Posted by cynosure

^^Quad core will be a dream for me.
I mean here for 15k I get both mobo and proc. but then I cud only get a pro.
waise you are talking bout intel or amd???

he he thats true...u will always have to pay a premium for intel motherboards..lol..
n i was talking abt intel quad core QX 6600...amd quad core for consumers has not been revealed!

[cynosure]

^^Then I am going to buy AMD X2 5600 only.
plan cancelled

I searched google and AMD was planning to launch their proc. in mid 2007
that means the procs will come out in the Q4 (coz its an AMD product)
I cant wait till then

[rahul30]

Originally Posted by cynosure

^^Then I am going to buy AMD X2 5600 only.
plan cancelled

I searched google and AMD was planning to launch their proc. in mid 2007
that means the procs will come out in the Q4 (coz its an AMD product)
I cant wait till then

amd x2 5600 will also be a great buy but do u have ne idea abt the prices,availability here in india and also does it come with 65nm tdp?

[premsharma]

Originally Posted by rahul30

buddy i went to the market today and these are the prices i got

1) amd x2 4800- rs 6175
amd x2 5200- rs 8450

2) biostar motherboard 690g (that guy said its sli and i dont think its possible)- rs. 5000

3) 1 gb ddr2 667 mhz ram- 2450
4)160gb hard disk sata- 2400

except for the motherboard i suppose everything is fixed...i m not really getting one point that this dealer is claiming that it is an atx motherboard sli with amd 690g...i have'nt found this anywhere in any websites??? u got any
idea?

No this biostar board is not ATX. It is mATX and it is not SLI either. It costs arround Rs 4100. Check theitwares.com for prices. Your dealer is mad. The only ATX in AMD 690G is from Gigabyte.

Originally Posted by magnet

i dont know why u ppl prefer amd when u shelving above 10k on mobo cpu.....

e4300 best stuff to buy if u have that much money...

i myself got an amd one today.....

amd 3600+ and jetway board...but will oc it to use at speed of 4600+ processer....i jus spended 6.8k on both...if htpc is the reason.. than its fine....

btw u wont find biostar board now...they have gone all nvidia now and jus 1-2 days bak they released one board...so i guess by end of the month ull get one but with nvidia chipset

Beacuse for C2D you have to spend 8- 10,000 for motherboard alone and that too with bekar onboard graphics. That is the precise reason we like AMD abd more over AMD 690G mobos have better onboard gfx at present and it cost between 3600 to 5100 for motherboard

Originally Posted by cynosure

Waise guys I thougt bout this config which I am going to buy maybe next month. Post your comments::

AMD Athlon 64 X2 5400+
Asus M2AVM-HDMI
2x2/1x4 GB 667MHz RAM (Going for a 64bit Linux)
Seagate 320GB SATA II HDD
Lite-On LH-20A1P DVD burner
Benq 17 '' FP71G LCD VDU
Any 2.1 speaker system (creative most prob.)
Logitech Keybord+mouse combo
APC 1KVA/800VA UPS
Cabinet with 600W PSU.

Your Config is superb. APC 800 VA is more than enough. It will cost you arround 5k. You can reconsider your mobo, because Asus M2AVM-HDMI comes with separate HDMI card which goes into PCI-E slot, that means lateron, if you want to add graphix card, then you have to remove this HDMI card. There is a board from MSI which has HDMI integrated but that one do not have DVI then. So the best choice should be 690G mobo from Biostar or Gigabyte. Biostar board has HDMI integrated as well as DVI. These all board are mATX execpt the gigabyte.

Consider 17" wide TFT from Viewsonic. 2.1 speakers wont do any justice to the system. Go for atleast 5.1 setup from Atris [kunhar Peripherals]. this should cost you arround 7K. SMPS you go for VIP powesafe and 500 watt should be sufficient. Rest everything looks OK

[cynosure]

^^
Biostar mobo is nice and cheap but I read its review over the net in here and its performance is not very good when it comes to anything (games, softwares etc.) And since I am making a gaming rig so this thing matters a lot.

You said Gigabyte, I checked it and its way better than Biostar

I dont think I will need HDMI coz I wont be connecting my PC to any TV or anything like that.

And you said VDU from Viewsonic; is that better???

And I think I'll be buying a good DX10 card (I am in love with 8800GT 640MB so thats why I was planning for a bigger PSU.

amd x2 5600 will also be a great buy but do u have ne idea abt the prices,availability here in india and also does it come with 65nm tdp?

Few days back the price on itwares was 9K but somehow they have increased the price to 11.5K. but this should be available for 9K.
This is available at any big computer shop or any big comp market.
AFAIK 5600+ has 90nm arch.

[premsharma]

See there are plenty of review sites, you should not take them seriously. I can quote you few, who have rated biostar a very good board but not for overclocking. Its price is also very nice and it has both HDMI & DVI. For a person like me who is looking for HDMI & DVI both integrated, have no other choice than Biostar presently. My another requirement is that I want ATX board which only Gigabyte has right now. Anyhow I don't like that gigabyte mobo look. So waiting for ATX mobo from MSI, Biostar or Asus. Considering these all points along with cost, it said it is best. If you are not intrested in HDMI, then Asus board would be best or MSI, Gigabyte etc. Even Jetway has 690G board, which merely costs 3600. Though Gigabyte board is ATX but I am not sure whether it has both DVI & HDMI and I don't know its cost either. It should also be a good board at par with Asus & MSI for costing purpose.

Yes, ofcourse ViewSonic TFTs are superior to others and very attractive prices. ViewSonic is fisrt to launch wide model in 17" TFT, which should be arround 8k+

[cynosure]

Gigabyte wont cost more than 6K thats for sure. And I have to buy a comp next month so I will be going for some rounds of Nehru Place after the 30th and then only I will be getting a knowhow bout the prices.

Till next month, ATX mobos of other companies wont be launched so I think I will have to buy Gigabyte only. And this mobo offers superb overclocking (way better than Biostar like you said) but thing is AMD procs dont support a good OC

I am confused bout going for Viewsonic or Benq as both of them have a good monitor range. A big NO NO to widescreens.

Thanks anyways dude!

[rahul30]

Originally Posted by premsharma

See there are plenty of review sites, you should not take them seriously. I can quote you few, who have rated biostar a very good board but not for overclocking. Its price is also very nice and it has both HDMI & DVI. For a person like me who is looking for HDMI & DVI both integrated, have no other choice than Biostar presently. My another requirement is that I want ATX board which only Gigabyte has right now. Anyhow I don't like that gigabyte mobo look. So waiting for ATX mobo from MSI, Biostar or Asus. Considering these all points along with cost, it said it is best. If you are not intrested in HDMI, then Asus board would be best or MSI, Gigabyte etc. Even Jetway has 690G board, which merely costs 3600. Though Gigabyte board is ATX but I am not sure whether it has both DVI & HDMI and I don't know its cost either. It should also be a good board at par with Asus & MSI for costing purpose.

Yes, ofcourse ViewSonic TFTs are superior to others and very attractive prices. ViewSonic is fisrt to launch wide model in 17" TFT, which should be arround 8k+

brother ur absolutely correct about the biostar motherboard...and majority of dealers in kolkata do not sell biostar ...i asked my dealer abt that biostar board...and he told him that he would provide from the distributor but he wont take any responsibility for the same as there is no proper channet of service of biostar boards atleast in kolkata...he also told me that in a way all the motherboard companies service is pathetic..still atleast from his side he would be able to do something in case a problem arised because other motherboards companies like asus msi etc have their offices set up properly in india and so its atleast better chance than biostar board...so be sure about the after sales service and then go for your buy!

[sagsall4u]

hey guys . ty for ur response . sorry cudn't reply, my really old pc conked off.
I havent included a gfx card coz i have to buy it with my own money later as my parents dont know that i'm a gamer.
The amd X2 5000 is directly a adversary to the intel C2D E6400 , the amd gives better performance in gaming that the C2D. (source xbitlabs)
As i said i quoted the prices from theitwares.com , the prices sum of you have given is definitely cheaper which i will look into when i actually go buy the rig.

And yeah, you guys should really go for asus or gigabyte instead of the new brands (wud u buy a tech-com speaker instead of altec lansing )
and what about Dx10 gfx cards . can sum1 give a clue bout which one has been released for what price.

[keith_j_snyder2]

^^^Well the answer is NVIDIA still got the LEAD.The card HD2900XT is targeted to kill the 640 MB 8800GTS but its costlier than 8800 GTS(640MB) & more power hungry.Even the 8800 GTX recommended PSU is 425watt but the min. required PSU for HD2900XT is 550 watt.There was the same story with 7900GTX & X1900XTX.No doubt that 1900XTX wins but 7900GTX lags with negligible score,but 7900GTX takes 78watts & X1900XTX sucks 130Watts.Thats the main difference.
The all new HD2900XT is really good but it sucks more power than 8800 ULTRA.
& besides this nVidia RULES!!!!
....because i also am a nVidian!

Also the 5000+ might be better than E6400 but the C2Duo is a better overclocker with the stock cooling because of 45nm fab.So its better to get a E6320 or E6420(4MB L2 Cache) rather than 5000+ or a E6400.

[ssk_the_gr8]

Originally Posted by keith_j_snyder2

^^^Well the answer is NVIDIA still got the LEAD.The card HD2900XT is targeted to kill the 640 MB 8800GTS but its costlier than 8800 GTS(640MB) & more power hungry.Even the 8800 GTX recommended PSU is 425watt but the min. required PSU for HD2900XT is 550 watt.There was the same story with 7900GTX & X1900XTX.No doubt that 1900XTX wins but 7900GTX lags with negligible score,but 7900GTX takes 78watts & X1900XTX sucks 130Watts.Thats the main difference.
The all new HD2900XT is really good but it sucks more power than 8800 ULTRA.
& besides this nVidia RULES!!!!
....because i also am a nVidian!

Also the 5000+ might be better than E6400 but the C2Duo is a better overclocker with the stock cooling because of 45nm fab.So its better to get a E6320 or E6420(4MB L2 Cache) rather than 5000+ or a E6400.

c2duo is 65nm not 45....