which is better? MSI-RS482IL or asusA8N-VM CSM

[reddragon]

which is better for playing latest games (like DOOM3 , FEAR,POP )
MSI-RS482IL or asusA8N-VM CSM

the asus board has NVIDIA® GeForce™ 6150 GPU
{The NVIDIA® GeForce™ 6150 GPU Northbridge supports Microsoft® DirectX 9.0 Shader Model 3.0, dual VGA out ( DVI-D and RGB), NVIDIA® PureVideo Technology with unprecedented integrated video quality, TV-out, and PCI Express interface. The NVIDIA® nForce™ 430 MCP Southbridge delivers NVIDIA® Gigabit LAN with ActiveArmor Firewall for secure networking, and NVIDIA® MediaShield storage management technology allowing easy RAID configuration (RAID 0, RAID 1, RAID 0+1, and RAID 5) for Serial ATA II. }

and MSI -rs482IL
{ATI® Radeon XPRESS 200 (RS482) Chipset
- HyperTransport™ connection to AMD K8 Athlon 64 processor
- 8 or 16 bit control/address/data transfer both directions
- 1GHz "Double Data Rate" operation both direction
- Compliant with PCI Express 1.0a specifications (one x16 graphics interface, which can be divided into two smaller links for use by other devices)
- Graphic integrated }



[/i]

[readermaniax]

nVIDIA GeForce 6150 motherboards pack in a lot of features that the AMD Athlon64 integrated graphics market has been seriously lacking. The chipset is destined to find resonance with system integrators looking to assemble affordable PCs based on the K8 architecture and with consumers who have similar goals. Core logic from nVidia has come a long way, and GeForce 6150 motherboards with their integrated Geforce 6 series GPU are being positioned at about half of what a high end nForce4 SLI motherboard will cost.

The Asus A8N-VM CSM motherboard looks like the perfect workstation/HTPC motherboard at first glance; onboard graphics with analog and DVI-D monitor outputs, and nVidia PureVideo High Definition MPEG-2/WMV9 Playback acceleration. The A8N-VM CSM supports all Socket 939 AMD Athlon64/FX/X2 processors on the market, and is built around two recent nVidia chipsets, the NVIDIA GeForce 6150 & nForce 430.

The board will support up to 4GB of dual channel PC3200 DDR400 RAM. Onboard features include IEEE 1394a, a 5.1 channel HDA (Azalia)/AC97 audio controller, Gigabit LAN and of course analog and DVI-D Geforce 6-series onboard video. Expansion is possible through PCI Express x16 and PCI Express x1 slots for high bandwidth devices and two 32 bit PCI slots for legacy devices.

The MicroATX form factor motherboard incorporates a full two channel IDE controller, and four SATA II ports for storage. Components are laid out well, so installation should be a snap. At the back of the Asus A8N-VM CSM are four USB2.0 ports, three audio headers, the Gigabit network and Firewire jacks, and Analog and DVI-D ports which connect directly to the Geforce 6 GPU.

Currently the Asus A8N-VM CSM is the only GeForce 6150 and nForce 430 motherboard on the market to support both analog and DVI-D output.

The onboard GeForce 6150 GPU will even accommodate dual monitors, which is a great feature for business users who would otherwise need to install a stand along graphics card for such functionality.

Note however that the DVI-D output is note quite the same as a DVI output. The DVI-D standard lacks four pins, and as such will not function with that spare DVI-to-analog converter you might have kicking around. If you plan to use dual monitors, one display must use an analog cable, and the other digital.

http://www.pcstats.com/artvnl.cfm?articleID=1898

[vijay_7287]

wat abt the cost

MSI board 4.5k
ASUS board 6k


for a lay MAN i guess the MSI board is the best

[nd4spd]

Yes there is a big difference in the cost.

but if u will see the pcstats.com link provided by readermaniax
you will see that there is no big difference in the rating they achieve in the tests conducted by them.

It is interesting to see that the FOXCONN 6150K8MA
which is based on the same (GeForce 6150 + nVidia 430) chipset perform distinguishingly well in those test.