22" Full HD Monitor

[static_x]

Hi,
I'm lookin for a full hd 22" lcd monitor. I just could not decide which one to buy....

LG 22'' HD Monitor with D-Sub/DVI port and HD Native Resolution 30000:1 DR 5 MS = 10500/-
Samsung 2233SW D-Sub/DVI 15000:1 5 MS = 10800/-
Benq E2200 Full HD D-sub / DVI-D/ HDM1.3 / Audio in / Headphone Jack 10000:1 5MS = 11800/-

All have 3 yrs of warranty. I've no idea about the Benq. I've never used it. Please suggest!!!

[The Sorcerer]

Stick to samsung 2233sw. Benq e2200 is a fantastic screen, but do you really want the speakers on the screen . In any case, both screens are good. You get benq T220HD which is without speakers and costs the same as 2233sw. In any case, both are fantastic buy.

[saqib_khan]

If u r comparing just 3 models, then u should go for 2233SW.

[nebujvs]

What is the Model No. of the LG monitor

is it LG L224WS ?

[static_x]

Originally Posted by nebujvs

What is the Model No. of the LG monitor

is it LG L224WS ?

LG W2243T

[static_x]

Originally Posted by saqib_khan

If u r comparing just 3 models, then u should go for 2233SW.

I just shortlisted these 3 models. If you've any better solution please let me know

[Cool G5]

Go with Samsung 2233SW. Good value for money.

[saqib_khan]

^^ True, stick with 2233SW only.

[static_x]

BenQ T2200 HD is for 9.5k
Samsung 2233SW for 10.8k
BenQ E2200HD is for 11.8k

I spoke to the Benq Service Centre head and he says that BenQ has the full replacement warranty against any defect or failure(3Yrs). I compared both Samsung & BenQ and found no visible difference in any of the models stated above. I think BenQ is not a bad bet and i can go with it. Now the only thing is which Model. E2200 has the HDMI and built in speakers and it costs roughly 2k more than T2200 model. So, what you say guys shall i stick with it or go with the T2200?

[desiibond]

My pick would be Samsung 2233SW too

Also, check Dell 2209W

[static_x]

Finally i'm going for Samsung 2233SW @10.5k........Thanks to you all for giving your valuable comments!!

[vilas_patil]

@static_x Check your pc (MotherBord) config. If your pc is too old then these new monitors cannot function smoothly (recommended Resolution).
It happen with me recently.
I have upgraded to Acer X193HQ (18.5) monitor for which latter I came to know that the recommended screen resolution[1366x768] cannot be set as the MotherBord is 4 years old. I even tried to install the drivers, but it was of no use. Finally I upgraded my motherbord. Fortunately it is my Office PC so expenses are not from my pocket.

[static_x]

Originally Posted by vilas_patil

@static_x Check your pc (MotherBord) config. If your pc is too old then these new monitors cannot function smoothly (recommended Resolution).
It happen with me recently.
I have upgraded to Acer X193HQ (18.5) monitor for which latter I came to know that the recommended screen resolution[1366x768] cannot be set as the MotherBord is 4 years old. I even tried to install the drivers, but it was of no use. Finally I upgraded my motherbord. Fortunately it is my Office PC so expenses are not from my pocket.

I'm upgrading my system. I'm going for AMD Phenom II X4 940 + Gigabyte 790GP UD4H Mobo+4 Gb 800MHz Corsair. So no scope for such problems !!

[saqib_khan]

^^He already told, he is going for Samsung 2233SW LCD.

[The Sorcerer]

BTW, samsung 2233sw comes only with VGA cable. You will have to purchase a dvi cable separatly.

[static_x]

Hey guys...yesterday i went for Samsung 2233SW...I saw the ACER's 23" Full HD panel, Model No. H233H priced at 11.8K and i must say that it has got a stunning build quality and the best part is, its feather touch control buttons with white back light. It has got 40000:1 DCR and 5ms RT,VGA, HDMI, DVI with HDCP inputs, 1920 x 1080 resolution, 300 cd/m2 brightness and 16:9 Aspect ratio. So, i put my Samsung deal for a hold I'll read more about this model and then I'll decide again. :-P

[rosemolr]

acer sucks in build quality..but i dont know about this case..anyway please tell us ur final pick.please i'am also going to upgrade ma monitor

[MetalheadGautham]

Spec wise, I think the LG Monitor beats the Samsung Monitor.

They tie in response time (5ms), original contrast ratio (1000:1), TDP (40W), etc.

But the dynamic contrast ratio of the LG which is 30000:1 is double that of samsung which is 15000:1. I have no idea though if the DC ratio affects real performance.

BenQ looses out on BOTH DC ratio (10000:1) and TDP (47W). But rest of the specs remain the same even here.

Price wise, BenQ is 9.5K while the other two are 10.8K, an Rs. 1300 difference which is significant IMO.

[static_x]

Originally Posted by rosemolr

acer sucks in build quality..but i dont know about this case..anyway please tell us ur final pick.please i'am also going to upgrade ma monitor

Even i had the same opinion about ACER. But this one is really good at least the build quality. I've read few reviews of the same model and it looks as if this one is good for non-gamers and as gaming is not my requirement, I may consider it.
If you see the specs then it beats all the other LCDs in DCR (it has got 40000:1). And in this price range this panel has got all the features.
I'll post my final decision and my review too if i buy this one...

[saqib_khan]

^^For those who want a review of Acer H233H, tech2 has a review here

But I don't think I can trust Acer. I would always go for Dell & Samsung. But that's what I think. Opinions differ.

[MetalheadGautham]

Originally Posted by saqib_khan

^^For those who want a review of Acer H233H, tech2 has a review here

But I don't think I can trust Acer. I would always go for Dell & Samsung. But that's what I think. Opinions differ.

The review itself is negative. They say it has very poor blacks and the colour contrast is not good.

Hmm.. if that's the case I would pay more attention to Samsung and LG.

BTW, does Sammy ship a HDMI to DVI-D adapter ?

[saqib_khan]

I will be purchasing 2233SW in a short time, its not available with my dealer also. So he said to wait 5 days approx. Therefore I will be waiting & then get ready for a review of it

But I don't think it will ship with a HDMI to DVI-D adapter , because others r saying it doesn't even ship with a DVI cable. Lets see what comes in the package.

[j1n M@tt]

My pick would be Dell 2209W.

[MetalheadGautham]

Originally Posted by j1n M@tt

My pick would be Dell 2209W.

Hmm... 2W higher TDP than Samsung. Any reviews btw ?
And BenQ is interesting too, especially because of the cheap price tag, but 47W TDP compared to LG/Sammy's 40W TDP kinda bugs me.

[just for the reference: my next rig will be an energy efficient workstation or a notebook]

[static_x]

I fully agree with you guys. Even I was convinced to buy Samsung. But then came to know about this one, so gave it a thought as well. The PC Mag review rates it pretty well and it can be found here http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2342887,00.asp
But yes,they also say that blacks are not that strong. So will it make a deeper impact on its performance? As gaming is not my motive.

[MetalheadGautham]

Originally Posted by static_x

I fully agree with you guys. Even I was convinced to buy Samsung. But then came to know about this one, so gave it a thought as well. The PC Mag review rates it pretty well and it can be found here http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2342887,00.asp
But yes,they also say that blacks are not that strong. So will it make a deeper impact on its performance? As gaming is not my motive.

Lack of strong blacks will:

1. Make gaming suck since you have dark areas.
2. In movies like The Matrix, with a lot of shades of black in same screen, effects will appear less cool.

[static_x]

See this!!

[MetalheadGautham]

Originally Posted by static_x

See this!!

yup. blacks don't look too good on the pics.
edit: I guess thats because of bad camera. even outside the monitor black sucks.

But I still need a comparison vs Sammy, LG and BenQ

[static_x]

Ha Ha Ha....finally have to be settled with Samsung Panel...the size of the ACER Panel is 561.6x393.9x177.5 mm (just noticed) and this won't fit on my PC Table...and I just can't replace my table...

[MetalheadGautham]

Originally Posted by static_x

Ha Ha Ha....finally have to be settled with Samsung Panel...the size of the ACER Panel is 561.6x393.9x177.5 mm (just noticed) and this won't fit on my PC Table...and I just can't replace my table...

An LCD only has its STAND on the table. Even if the screen goes outside the table, if the stand stays in then its balenced.

And most stands are small enough to fit on a Stool