RATE the game you've Played

[s18000rpm]

Simple, just rate the games you've played so far.


Racing Games

Simulation

->F1 Challenge ('99-'02) - 10/10.

->Richard Burns Rally (RBR) - 8/10 (the only fully blown sim. Rally game)

->Colin McRae 04 & 05 - 7/10 & 9/10 (former lacked cars & tracks)

->NFS Porsche Unleashed - 10/10 (the best NFS, & best sim. racing title, loads of details)

->Evolution GT & GTi Racing 5/10 (both), too much of uneccessary gameplay in EvoGT (like driver emotions)



Arcade Games

->NFS Most Wanted - 9/10 (gorgeous gfx., good storyline, nice engine capture)

->NFS Carbon - 5/10 (5 for realistic engine sound & car collection)

->NFS II - 9/10 (still the best)

->NFS HP2 - 8/10 (nice game with tought cops & BMW M5)
(other NFS didnt interest me much)

->MidNight Club 2 - 4.5/10 (no comments)

=========

Third-Person Shooters

->GTA3 - 8/10 - superb at that time. (but buggy gfx.)

->GTA VC - 10/10 - Nice location, gameplay & story was good & Tommy Vercetti, still the coolest8)

->GTA SA - 9/10 - nice loooong story, location, gameplay, ok story.

->Max Payne 1 & 2 - 8/10 (both), the Prologue chapter was irritating

->Mafia - 10/10, superb story, gameplay....

->HitMan Contracts - will rate after completing

->GodFather - no rating, gfx. was cheap, too much arcady gameplay (plyer control), just 4/5 car models

(no FPS)

[Third Eye]

Thanks for creating this thread s18000rpm

The Elder Scrolls IV Oblivion -> 9.8/10
Grand Theft Auto San Andreas -> 9.5/10
Serious Sam The Second Encounter->9/10
Hitman Code Name 47 -> 8/10
Hitman 2 Silent Assassin 9/10
Hitman Contracts 6/10
Hitman Blood Money 9/10
Halo Combat Evolved -> 9/10
Halo 2 ->9/10
Battlefield 2 -> 9.5/10
Battlefield 2142 -> 8.5/10
Flatout 7/10
Flatout 2 -> 9/10
The Godfather -> 9.2/10
Pirates of the Carribean: At Worlds's End -> 3/10
Splinter Cell Double Agent -> 8.5/10
Overload -> 6/10
Need for speed Carbon -> 8/10
Need for speed most wanted -> 9/10
Need for speed U2 -> 5/10
Need for speed Undergound 8/10
Trackmania United -> 8.5/10
Test Drive Unlimited -> 9.3/10
GTA Vice City 9.5/10
Half Life 2 -> 9.5/10
Half Life EP 1 -> 8/10
Fear 9/10
Gothic 8/10
Cars 7/10
Toca Race Driver 9.1/10
LOTR:BFME2 -> 9.3/10
Max Payne -> 9/10
Max Payne 2 -> 9.5/10
Doom 3 7/10
COD 2 8/10
Splinter Cell Pandora Tomorrow 9/10
Prey 8/10
Splinter Cell Chaos Theory 9/10
Midtown Madness ->8/10
Midtown Madness 2 -> 8.2/10
WWE RAW 5/10
Monster Truck Madness 1 -> 4/10
Monster Truck Madness 2 -> 5/10
Serious Sam 2 -> 7.5/10
Need for speed hot pursuit 2 -> 9.2/10
Commandos Beyond the call of duty -> 3/10
Evolution GT 7/10
Peggle Deluxe 10/10
Sims 2 8.8/10
GTA 3 9/10
Cricket 2002 8.5/10
Cricket 2004 3/10
Cricket 2005 7/10
Cricket 2007 8/10
Brian Lara 2005 9/10
Brian Lara 2007 9.5/10
NBA Live 2007 7/10

[Arsenal_Gunners]

I ll start from the most recentOnly computer games,no nes
Company of heroes-9(haven't finished)
The elder scrolls 4 oblivion+shivering isles-10\10(never had so much of fun in any game)
PES6-6.7
Conter strike Source -9 just for Single player
Fifa manger -6(got bored after 1st season)
Splinter CellT -8.5
Splinter Cell:CT- 8
Half life 2+Episode 1-9.8
Half life- 9.7
GTA SA-9.7(nice big game)
GTA VC-9.8(More satisfying than SA in my opinion)
GTA 3 - 8.5( gfx sucked,but loved the umm..innovative taxi drivers)
GTA 2 - 6
GTA - 8(one of my first games,hell of a fun)
Delta Force 1 - 9
D.F. 2 - 7/10
D.F. 4 - 7/10
Mafia- 9.3 (great theme and story)
Battlefield 2 - 8.7(would have given 10 if I had played MP properly)
Max payne 1 - 8.5
Max payne 2 - 9.3(sad ambiance)
F-16 Aggressor- 9(arcade-sim)
Fifa 07 8.8 (never played such a fun soccer game)
F.E.A.R. 8 (nice fights,but monotonus)
Doom3 - 7 ( booooooring)
America's Army - 8 (free mp yay)
Call of duty - 9.5
Call of duty 2 - 8.5(tank missions kicked ass,most of the rest were average)
Warcraft 3 - 10 (one of the best I have ever played)
Rise of nations - 9 (you get nukes YAY)
Far cry 9.6 - (Nice gameplay and graphics)
Return to Castle Wolfenstien 9.5 (first game I had,some levels can scare you sh1tless)
Prince of Persia WW - 8.5
Prince of Persia T2T- 8
Sims 2 - 5 (no surprise I forgot this)
WWE RAW-6
Commandos 2- 7\10 (maybe it was beyond the CoD)
Cricket 2005- 5.5 (sport itself suck)
NBA Live 2003 - 9/10
Counter Strike:CZero - 7
Army men - 7.5
NHL 06 - 7 (you could fight the opponent too)
Fifa WC 02 - 9 (I got hooked at fifa from this game)
Operation desert storm - 7
Age of empires 2 - 8
Thats all I can remember,Ill add more if they come to my mind
I have played some racing games too,but since I suck at at them I wouldnt rate.
----------------------------------
Loooool mine and s18's ideas match in few games

[chicha]

Mafia 10/10
(+ very nice and neat graphics, VERY NICE story, Great cars)

Godfather 7/10
(+Very Very nice story,
(-Very cheap looking graphics, hopeless car details)

Maxpayne 1,2 (9.5/10) (9.5/10)
(+Great story line, Good gameplay, Bullet Dodge,
(PROLOUNGE chapter the hopeless of all the levels ever disgned in game history)

oni 10/10
(+ great graphics, good gameplay, nice hand to hand combact, nice story)

Indiana Jones and the infernal machine 9.5/10
(+Good game play, nice story, the whip, nice blend between action and adventure,
(- Veeeeery long, not so good graphics).

Tomb Raider 1/10
(+lora croft,
(-----Every thing else).

[Stalker]

F.E.A.R. >> 9.1/10
+ Awesome gfx, unique story
- Demanding on hardware, scary

Half-Life 2 + EP1 >> 9.2 / 10
+ good gfx, physics, gameplay, not demanding on hardware
- disappointing ending....always leaves u hanging

FarCry >> 9.0 / 10
+ open landscape gives u multiple ways of approaching our objective.
- pretty hard on difficulty

Splinter Cell : Chaos theory >> 8.9 / 10
+ great stealth game, great mp ( haven't played double agent though)
- didn't find any..

Max PAyne 1 & 2 >> 8.7 / 10
+ great gfx, gameplay, Awesome story....
- None!!

Prince Of persia : Sand of time >> 9 / 10
+ lovely story, cute gfx
- Not many combos, basically defend & then attack... can be monotonous

Prince Of Persia: Warrior Within >> 7 / 10
+ good gfx, Free-form fighting
- Should have never been made, Hopeless storyline!!

Prince of Persia : The two thrones >> 8.3 / 10
+ some cool new tricks, gfx remain the same, tries to somehow stabilize the mess they have made in warrior within.
- Bad camera angles during some boss fights

NFS: Most Wanted >> 9.1 / 10
+ awesome gfx / story for a NFS game, not much emphasis on car styling just pure racing / cop-evading fun
- Poor physics, Cars behave like trucks sometimes

NFS: Carbon >> 7 / 10
+ good car collection, new concept of CREW, good lighting
- Career very short, poor value for money

Warcraft 3: RoC & TFT >> 9.3/ 10
+ one of the best fantasy based RTS games, well balanced gameplay
- None!

Hitman : Blood Money >> 9.3 / 10
+ great gameplay, beautiful gfx, customizations of weapons, notoriety

Will add more as i remember...

[bkpeerless]

doom 3 9/10
cod 2 8/10
quake 4 8.5/10
maxpayne 1&2 11/10
nfs mw 9/10
jacked 6/10
splinter cell ct , pt, 1 - 8,9,10 /10

[baccilus]

Originally Posted by Tech Genius

Thanks for creating this thread s18000rpm

The Elder Scrolls IV Oblivion -> 9.8/10
Grand Theft Auto San Andreas -> 9.5/10
Serious Sam The Second Encounter->9/10
Hitman Code Name 47 -> 8/10
Hitman 2 Silent Assassin 9/10
Hitman Contracts 6/10
Hitman Blood Money 9/10
Halo Combat Evolved -> 9/10
Halo 2 ->9/10
Battlefield 2 -> 9.5/10
Battlefield 2142 -> 8.5/10
Flatout 7/10
Flatout 2 -> 9/10
The Godfather -> 9.2/10
Pirates of the Carribean: At Worlds's End -> 3/10
Splinter Cell Double Agent -> 8.5/10
Overload -> 6/10
Need for speed Carbon -> 8/10
Need for speed most wanted -> 9/10
Need for speed U2 -> 5/10
Need for speed Undergound 8/10
Trackmania United -> 8.5/10
Test Drive Unlimited -> 9.3/10
GTA Vice City 9.5/10
Half Life 2 -> 9.5/10
Half Life EP 2 -> 8/10
Fear 9/10
Gothic 8/10
Cars 7/10
Toca Race Driver 9.1/10
LOTR:BFME2 -> 9.3/10
Max Payne -> 9/10
Max Payne 2 -> 9.5/10
Doom 3 7/10
COD 2 8/10
Splinter Cell Pandora Tomorrow 9/10
Prey 8/10
Splinter Cell Chaos Theory 9/10
Midtown Madness ->8/10
Midtown Madness 2 -> 8.2/10
WWE RAW 5/10
Monster Truck Madness 1 -> 4/10
Monster Truck Madness 2 -> 5/10
Serious Sam 2 -> 7.5/10
Need for speed hot pursuit 2 -> 9.2/10
Commandos Beyond the call of duty -> 3/10
Evolution GT 7/10
Peggle Deluxe 10/10
Sims 2 8.8/10
GTA 3 9/10

Wow ! You have played so many games. You have completed them all? Even Arsenal is a big time gamer . And I thought I am addicted.

[Arsenal_Gunners]

Lol I have mentioned only big games(that too I have played in recent times)that list consists about half of the games i playedex-I have played 5-6 flight sims but I rated only 1

@ tech- you work in valve or what,already played Episode 2

[Third Eye]

^^sorry it was mistake. corrected

[BULLZI]

cs 1.6 multiplayer-more than 10 out of 10
the clan wars,they are really challenging,interesting n mind blowing too

aoe2 multiplayer 10 out of 10
lill bit time consumin bt tht s ok

mafia 10 out of 10
really good story line n theme

farcry 10 out of 10
excellent graphics n actions

f.e.a.r.
still to rate,just started

doom3 6 out of 10
boring

max payne1 8 out of 10

max payne2 7 out of 10

pop sands of time
still to be rated

pop warrior within
still to be rated

desert storm 8 out of 10
liked its team game policy

[hell_storm2004]

jat wanted 2 add

NHL 07 --- 12/10!!!!! best ea game of all!!!!
Madden 07 --- 9.5/10!!!!

[s18000rpm]

GTR2 - 10/10

(fully blown Sim., endless tuning options , i'm still in driving school, but getting GOLD medal in all of them...so far)

[hard_rock]

I played mostly Stealth action and story based games.. NFS is the only racing game I played.

Racing games:

Roadrash-9/10 (For the KICKING FUN it gave)

NFS II- 8/10 (First racing game I played many hours for which I payed around 60Rs. at some computer center..that too for just playing game.. I feel myself stupid for that now)

NFS-Porsche-10/10 (Still remember how much happy I was when I played it on my old P3 machine..It was a state of art graphics which I saw then)

NFS-Underground-10/10 (The first "fully customisable car" race..Learnt a lot about cars from it)

NFS-Mostwanted-8/10 (All credit goes to superb graphics with that warm colour temperature)

TPS:
James Bond:Nightfire- 8/10 (First TPS action game I played. Felt like bond using those cool gadgets)

Mafia: The max. rating + 1 googol ..(Still the best game I played in my life. Excellent story..Thought provoking dialogues..)

Max Payne2 : 9/10 (For immersive gameplay with excellent story narration)

IGI 2: 9/10 (Introduced me to an element called STEALTH.. Using BRAINS instead of ONLY GUNS.. It made me realise that YES...STEALTH ACTION GAME is my GENRE )

GTA: VC - 6/10 (I played it around 15-20% but dint found time and interest to complete the game.. But enjoyed listening to RADIO on the HARLEY DAVIDSON bike doing wheelie.. a 6 for that)

Splinter Cell-Pandora Tomorrow: 9/10 (Introduced me to a whole new world of a SPY.. SAM FiSCHEr..A completely different gameplay with multiple opportunites move forward+ STEALTH+NEW GADGETS made me a fan of this series)

Hitman-Blood money: 10/10 (I was appointed as AGENT 47 through this . The bald headed, bar coded person became my favourite after TOMMY of mafia. Also the music of Jesper Kyd in the game made me hard core fan of this)

Splinter Cell:Chaos Theory- 8/10 (Inspired by SCT I played this..)

Hitman Silent Assassin-9/10 (Played this after HBM. Graphics reminded me of MAFIA.. But a lil bit different gameplay from Blood Money took little time for me to adjust)

Hitman-Contracts (I'm playing it right now..Will rate after completion)
Splinter Cell: Double Agent -YET TO PLAY
Sniper elite: yet to play for my fav. SNIPING action+Stealth. Donno how it is??

Sword games:
POP:SOT- 7/10 (Played it after playing POP T2T partially.. Initially I thought sword games are boring..But story was good that I couldnt resist to play from start of series.)

POP:WW-8/10 (Played it partially.. but I should rate it for excellent moves,graphics and dark shaded environment.. But too much violent unlike a softer prince as in POP SOT..)

POP:T2T : I have played it partially before starting this series..Then switched to POP SOT to track the story.. Now have to play it afresh as save games are missing

Thief Series: yet to play for its stealth element.

[Arsenal_Gunners]

^^Weird IGI and NFS games getting max ratings

[BULLZI]

actually when i started igi 2, the experience was totally different from igi1.
the ai has become tremendously high in igi2 than thats in igi1.
really hv to make ur brain work a bit.
even there r some stages where u dont hv ta waste a bullet either n u can complete the stage successfully.

[hard_rock]

@arsenal_gunners:
I've rated the games depending upon the factor that "HOW MUCH THEY ROCKED ME.." while playing. And also the game is rated without comparing to any other newer game. For eg. IGI2 stealth is no way match to that of splinter cell, FEAR game AI is far better than IGI2 AI..

The time when I played those..They were the leading games then. Who knows after 10 years Splinter cell may look old and crappy(in technical aspects) as compared to the future ones.

I've not included the ones which I dislike.. Like Doom3..Just shoot shoot shoot and run. I dont like FPS. So ME talking about that game is inappropriate coz its not my genre. It may be rocking for FPS lovers.

In racing games, I've played just one or two tournaments of rally games like F1 . I felt that boring because its just go round and round for 50+ laps. Instead additional elements like Vinyls, Drift,Drag racing etc gives variety in play.

Its my personal opinion. Since you've played so many games, I think these games may not appeal you much as compared to them.

[Arsenal_Gunners]

^^No,I am not comparing it to SC or FEAR,I am just saying it was pretty ordinary for its time too.
its ok if it is your openion

[hullap]

Pes6-10\10

[gangadhar]

Commandos: Men Of Courage 9/10
Commandos: Destination Berlin 7/10
Commandos: Strike Force 4/10
Serious Sam: Second Encouter 8/10
Serious Sam:First Encounter 9/10
Splinter Cell: Pandora Tomorow 9/10
Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory 8.5/10
Splinter Cellouble Agent 8.5/10
POP: T2T 8.5/10
Far Cry 9.0/10
King Kong 9.0/10
Dark Mesiah M&M 9/10
Indiana Jones Emperor Tomb 8.5/10
Call Of thulhu: Dark Corner Of The Earth 10/10
Resident Evil IV 10/10
Tomb Raider: Legend 8.5/10
Tomb Raider: Anniversary 9.5/10

[rakeshishere]

NFS MW- 9.5/10 (Awesome Music and nice Cop Chasing)
Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes- 9/10 (Awesome Stealth Game)
Trackmania United- 8/10 (Good GamePlay)
Dave- 10/10 (Who doesn't like it)

Will add more as soon as i Remember ,but I am not so addicted to Gaming

[comrade]

Prince of Persia - (10/10)
POP 2 - (8/10)
POP 3D - (6/10)
POP-SOT - (9/10)
POP- WW - (9.5/10)
POP - TT - (9/10)
NFS Porshe Unleashed - (10/10)
Doom3 - (7/10)
Max Payne - (8/10)
18 Wheels of steel: ACross America (8/10)
18 WHeels of Steel: Haulin (7/10)
Brian Lara Cricket 99 - (9/10)
Cricket 2002 - (8/10)

[entrana]

All my games which i can remember

1. Scarface = 9/10, neat graphics, requirements not high, good gameplay
2. ES Oblivion+shiveringisles+knights of the 9= 10/10 , best damn rpg the ever set foot on the gaming world according to me,god damn graphics are good
3. Attack on pearl harbor=7/10, good flight combat simulator, it doesent require cd key to play online yay piracy,controls suck u need a josystick or 360 controller
4. the movies stunts and effects= 5/10, game not that good online is not what u think it is, at max u can be amused by it in 1 day
5. NWN2= 8/10 dont like the turn by turn system sheesh its old, fine gameply, not amazing graphics
6. The Longest Journey=10/10 super good story addicting, not good graphics duhhh its releaed it 1999
7. Dreamfall longest journey 2= 8.9/10 REALLY good story as well, good graphics, doesent require horrendous system requirements
8. titan quest+immortal throne= 9/10, finally a good ripoff of diablo 2
9. far cry= 9/10 good graphics for a 2004 game, realistic type not that realistic, i THINK it has hdr not sure, good fun gameplay
10. Stalker Shadow of Chernobyl= 9.4/10 good game, good graphics, doesent require a good system gameplay is fun, a new kind of genre
11. Half life 1= 9.5 excellent game u must try
12. Half Life 2=9.4 half life 1 was more exciting
13. Max Payne= 9/10 good game
14. Max Payne 2=9/10 see above
15. Command And Conquer 3= 9.6/10 good gameplay and fun online play, nice graphics for a rts
16. MoHPA= 8.5/10 good game, bored of ww2 games
17. CoH= 9.6/10 one of the best rts ever, still bored of ww2 games
18. age of empire 3= 5/10 WTF microsoft sucked at this dont even bbother buying this
19. Civilization 4+ warlords= 9/10 fun game u can stretch one game to more than 2 hours without getting bored, didnt try online but definitely a must have
20. gta san andreas= 9.5/10 dont know why its that good to get 9.9/10 from ign
21. half life 2 episode 1= 8/10 could have been better crappy game just the contrinuation of half life 2
22. sims2+pets+university+open for business+glamour life stuff+holiday edition+family fun stuff+ hm fashion stuff+seasons+nightlife=9.6 good game, not fun without all the expansions, really fun to play and really boring to play with cheats
23. lotr bfme2 rise of the withc king= 9.6/10 ahh yes, the classic rts is back and not boring at all
24. cod2= 8/10 , god damn dont people get bored of ww2 shooters
25. battlefield 2142= 8/10 for single player, 10/10 for online u need a powerful 1mbps internet to enjoy
26. hitman contracts= 8/10 i dont want to explain on this one
27. hitman silent assassin= 9/10 i think this is the best hitman
28. flatout2= 9/10 a fun racing game and u dont need a cd key to play online yay piracy
29. nfs carbon= 8/10 fine game not awesome what happened to nfs these days there goes the glory days
30. splinter cell pandora tomorrow= 9/10 i love tom clancy games
31. rainbow six raven shield= 9/10 good graphics with low requirements and good gameplay too
32. the simpsons hit and run= 8.5/10 imagine gta the simpsons style weeeeeeeeeeeeeee

make this thread sticky please it could help people decide for games just sayin

[ashisharya]

fifa 07- 9.5
aoe- 9

[Third Eye]

Driver : Parallel Lines

3/10 (Worst game of the century)

Horrid controls,boring missions
Cars,buses,bikes have almost same sound.
Worst GTA Clone

[Arsenal_Gunners]

^^Its not that bad,look at the player scores
http://www.gamespot.com/pc/driving/d...g=tabs;reviews

[entrana]

^^^ur the noob

[xbonez]

cut it out guys

[Arsenal_Gunners]

@ tech-Thats a fair score

[Stalker]

hey arsenal_gunners............entrana didnt call u a noob.................there was a post by tech saying that the gamespot / reviewers are noobs...........so entrana has replied to that.........

looks like tech has deleted his post

[Arsenal_Gunners]

Oops
I tried so hard to make that reply
TECH