Forum     

Go Back   Digit Technology Discussion Forum > Bandwidth Wastage > Fight Club
Register FAQ Calendar Mark Forums Read

Fight Club The Debate Zone. Sensitive and controversial topics will be discussed here — only the thick-skinned should enter

View Poll Results: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???
Of course! Gandhigiri rocks! 4 15.38%
Satyagraha is useless against terrorism! 22 84.62%
May be, may be not. 0 0%
Voters: 26. You may not vote on this poll

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 11-09-2006, 06:09 PM   #1 (permalink)
Apprentice
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 62
Question Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Do u guys think that terrorists can be defeated by Satyagrah?? There have been uncountable wars in the world....would there be any change if we resort to non-violence and use peaceful methods to solve the problem as Gandhiji once said??
freakanomics is offline  
Advertisements. Register and be a member of the community to get rid of them.
Advertisement

Old 11-09-2006, 06:25 PM   #2 (permalink)
Broken In
 
Anand_RF's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Uranus
Posts: 183
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

LOL Nope.
Look what satyagraha did. Two new countries, Pak and Bangladesh were created coz Gandhi wanted non-violence. And as far as I'm concerned, Pakistan is the root cause of all terrorism. And Bangladesh is their partner.
Besides, the UN practices non-violence. What is it able to do to stop wars?
This is just my opinion btw.
Anand_RF is offline  
Old 14-09-2006, 04:01 PM   #3 (permalink)
Mobile Freak
 
reddick's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Chandhigarh - Punjab
Posts: 647
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Why did u fget Bhagat Singh,C.S Azad,Rajguru,Sukhdev,Jhansi Ki Rani,Tipu Sultaan etc. who fought n died to keep us alive in free air. War can also be won by battles
__________________
Hope 4 d best n Do d right
reddick is offline  
Old 14-09-2006, 04:37 PM   #4 (permalink)
String Phreak
 
mediator's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: In ur Evil Mind!
Posts: 2,453
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Thats right the actual heroes of Indian Independence were people like Bhagat Singh who created terror in the minds of Britishers and scared the hell outa them. All Gandhiji did was playing politics and Nehru was a pawn for him. He was much poplular then Nehru. If he was so great then why didnt he became the country leader instead of Nehru and telling him what to do everytime? Because of him many innocent people died.
On one hand he was trying to tell britishers non-vilently to leave India and on other ruining the lives of innocent people. All britishers needed to do is renew their supplies of bullets to kill the non-violent supporters. No, Sataygraha is stupid and is just another name for politics.

Our real heroes are forgotten by the masses. They are the one who really contributed to Indian Independence. Who wanna live in a country where terror is gaining pace?? and thats what our heroes did creating terror all around Britishers leaving them with no choice. They were doomed to leave the country eventually!

My salute to our real heroes!

Neways for Pakistan....we dont really need to fight them! Their country will dismantle soon according to an American scientist. All we need to do is stenghten our defences and vigility against terrorists!
mediator is offline  
Old 14-09-2006, 04:41 PM   #5 (permalink)
GUNNING DOWN TEAMS
 
wizrulz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: MUMBAI
Posts: 1,724
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

DID THE THREAD ORGINATOR JUST SAW

LAGE RAHO .............MUNNABHAI...

this all can happen only in flims dude....in this age.... it cannot happen.......
just u imagine..for matter of example..if today anyone slaps u..r u gona put ur face forward for another one....????
terrorist r going way way beyond that.......so what u feel now ????
__________________
The moment U stop learning ......u stop improving
wizrulz is offline  
Old 14-09-2006, 05:08 PM   #6 (permalink)
Broken In
 
executioner's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Right behind u
Posts: 139
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

if anyone slaps me for no reason surely i am never gonna slap him
I am gonna kick him
executioner is offline  
Old 14-09-2006, 06:44 PM   #7 (permalink)
left this forum longback
 
praka123's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: -
Posts: 7,513
Talking Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

where is the POLL we need to see the satyagraha believers!about Rashtrapitha i remember the film "he..raam" of Kamal Haasan
__________________
left this forum long back.Admin Can Delete this Account and posts Permanantly.Thank You
Get GNU/Linux - http://getgnulinux.org
praka123 is offline  
Old 14-09-2006, 07:54 PM   #8 (permalink)
Distinguished Member
 
anandk's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Pune
Posts: 3,783
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Gandhi-giri wont work...
an eye-for-an-eye policy wont work
BUT
a head-for-an-eye policy will work !!!
__________________
> www.TheWindowsClub.com <
= www.WinVistaClub.com =
Microsoft® MVP
anandk is offline  
Old 14-09-2006, 08:41 PM   #9 (permalink)
HELP AND SUPPORT
 
rakeshishere's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 1,595
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Satyagraha-KMA ...Who the heck can still be a like a gandhi in this century
rakeshishere is offline  
Old 14-09-2006, 10:17 PM   #10 (permalink)
nix
Senior Member
 
nix's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Bangalore
Posts: 646
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

gandhigiri wont work w/neighbours...what will it work against terrorists
__________________
nikhilspoliticalblog.wordpress.com- Common man bows to amitabh
nix is offline  
Old 18-09-2006, 08:14 PM   #11 (permalink)
King of my own Castle
 
freshseasons's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Humor and wit.
Posts: 1,238
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Personally i think Gandhiji was the greatest leader the world ever had. Bhagat Singh no doubt was great but frankly i dont think Britishers were terrorised of him or others. They hanged him when they felt the need. I think Britishers were more Terrorised of Gandhiji because he had world Approval behind him forget our counties. When news of Dadi yatra Speard over , all the people from over the world pressurised Britshers to release him.
Gandhiji was so strong that Britishers couldnt even think to hang him like other . This is i think , the real Power.Satyagraha is the form of ultimate truth and truth is the real power. We will great lots of leader in this world but there will only be one Gandhiji...
Ok.....now about the question ? Yes ..if it were Afghanistan people fighting taliban.But "NO" if its kashmir terrorists as the enemy is really unkown. And more importantly i think satyagraha works when you dont have the power on things but take the purity of heart route to appease the one in power. Here we have power in hand .Example...
A father cannout use satyagraha against his 2 year old Child so that he attends school.
Stick is the only route here as father holds the power between them for the betterment of child.
But if the Father is wrong the child can do satyagraha until his father stops Drinking..
So this is where Satyagraha works
freshseasons is offline  
Old 18-09-2006, 09:09 PM   #12 (permalink)
String Phreak
 
mediator's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: In ur Evil Mind!
Posts: 2,453
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

@Freshseasons.....Bro the topic reads satyagraha against terrorists, ones who are cold blooded murderers and dont think anything save killing. And you are giving example of father and child? There's no comparison of satyagraha against terrorst and satyagraha against father or child!

As for GandhiJi being released, britishers had to do so coz he was the voice of Indian people. He made Indian calm and told them to excercise non-violence. If he had been killed then I think we wud have achieved Independence much earlier.

And dont forget about Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose....who had the Japanses backup behind him. HE had formed the Indian army too! And if I remember correctly the history books then Britishers were afraid of handling another front and that too against a sworn enemy that time.
I think Japan was part of Triple Axis right? I forgot the group!

So you see Britishers had no alternative but to leave because of
1. Growing pressure and fights around their own motherland
2. Growing violence/terror by Indians against them
3. Fear of japanese coming to India and starting a new battle front.

There may be more but these are the few I can remember right now!

And after achieving victory Indians had to declare independence quickly because they feared Japan might take interest in India after Britishers!

Gandhiji was just a pawn for Britishers to calm down the Indians who were burning with rage!
__________________
Bad Bad server.....No candy for u!
mediator is offline  
Old 18-09-2006, 09:46 PM   #13 (permalink)
left this forum longback
 
praka123's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: -
Posts: 7,513
Post Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???
personally i think the terror in the world is sponsored by wahhabis
as many in the forums knows.in my home state kerala these ppl(wahaabis) influenced mopla's and formed many charity soceities and political parties like NDF which disguises as parties working for national cause growing terrorism.who the hell is gonna control these shall we put satyagaraha infront of these ppl?
__________________
left this forum long back.Admin Can Delete this Account and posts Permanantly.Thank You
Get GNU/Linux - http://getgnulinux.org
praka123 is offline  
Old 18-09-2006, 09:50 PM   #14 (permalink)
In The Zone
 
go_gamez's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: navi mumbai
Posts: 417
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

i dnno about this...weather satyagraha and gandhiji can fight terrorism..but all i want to say is LAGEYRAHO MUNNABHAI REALLY TOUCHED MY HEART !!
__________________
Intel P4 2.47 ghz with 1 MB L2 cache-HIS 845GVM mobo
512 MB DDR RAM .
Gainward 6600 gt golden sample edition(ultra 1960xp)
80 GB Seagate Barracuda 7200 rpm HDD
Sony QW -120A Dual Layer DVD writer.
go_gamez is offline  
Old 18-09-2006, 10:18 PM   #15 (permalink)
Wise Old Crow
 
blueshift's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Inside the Pixel
Posts: 1,227
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

yes definately...
....if this happened 60 years back!
__________________
http://twitter.com/blueshift155
blueshift is offline  
Old 19-09-2006, 03:09 PM   #16 (permalink)
King of my own Castle
 
freshseasons's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Humor and wit.
Posts: 1,238
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

@ Mediator what are you saying.. " Gandhiji was a pawn in Britishers Hands"? Are you sure this is even worth duscussing forget fighting...
I dont like getting personal but buddy you have a huge Imagination.Can any day Give Romila Thapar Run for the money.
Ok i am not going to contest the point whether gandhiji was pawn under the hands of Britishers or not.The thought is simply beyond me. But i definatly have got this to tell....
Its very easy to say Britishers Released Gandhi coz he was voice of india. What does one mean by voice of india.Its so easy to say one is voice of india but ever imagined what it must take to be voice of india. It means literally having whole of the nation's support behind one .Did any leader ever have voice of India till now..
Earlier India was divided into moderates and extremists..Radical elements in society and some usurping here and there. It was Gandhiji who almost brought nation into one Form of leadership. Earlier it was just bits of struggle..infact not really a sense of nationalism for freedom just something indefinate.Congress Would never have got the major stake for demanding had Gandhiji not been there to unite them..
Jinha and Nehru because of their Stupidity almost had torn apart struggle for freedom ..by making huge gap between congress and muslim league. It was Gandhiji who united them and Make them work for freedom together.
Subhash Chandra Bose was definatly difficult fighter for the British but not someone for whom they would let India Go. British infact never were much bothered About Japan coz japan never supported India openly . Moreever After the Hiroshima and Nagasaki Atomic bombing on August 6, 1945 , Japan was done for good.Subhash Chandra Bose did make All India Forward Bloc party but was not much sucessful and he was imprisoned more than 11 times during that period ..later he fled to japan and helped and made Indian National Army, put together from Indian prisoners-of-war and plantation workers from Singapore and other parts of Southeast Asia.He Died later in a Plane Crash( Ok that itself is a debate but upon that later). See he was a Great Person and i really admire him.But Truth demands nothing but hard Truth. And He did help india amongst many factors for Gaining Fredom but was not the factor or the Main Reason India Got Freedom.
Truth why India Got Freedom:-
1)Quit India Movement in 1942 was a mass protest that broke British for the First time.
2)Government favorable to Indian freedom won the post-war election in England Which heavily favoured India being Independant.
3)Continuosly for 20 years, non-violent protests and marches and strikes by the Indians wore down British resistance to end. Confronted by a man wearing only a plain cloth and accompanied by millions of followers armed not with weapons but love and truth, the British government in 1946 finally decied to let go India.
4)Propably India is the only country where The fight for freedom had been won without a battle having ever been fought.
I dont want to fight it really after this nor i have time...you believe whatever you have to...truth will always be there. Peace Mate
freshseasons is offline  
Old 19-09-2006, 03:32 PM   #17 (permalink)
digit_fan
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Thumbs down Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Quote:
Originally Posted by mediator
Thats right the actual heroes of Indian Independence were people like Bhagat Singh who created terror in the minds of Britishers and scared the hell outa them. All Gandhiji did was playing politics and Nehru was a pawn for him. He was much poplular then Nehru. If he was so great then why didnt he became the country leader instead of Nehru and telling him what to do everytime? Because of him many innocent people died.
On one hand he was trying to tell britishers non-vilently to leave India and on other ruining the lives of innocent people. All britishers needed to do is renew their supplies of bullets to kill the non-violent supporters. No, Sataygraha is stupid and is just another name for politics.
have you lost your mind, ganghiji is a national hero, and you call him a politician, how can you be such a ediot, you are one stupid man i have ever heard, mediator kill your self before you say something like that.


and about bhagat singh, you should respect them, no doubt, he is our hero,

and stop comparing heros, Ganghiji is very different from other heros on indian independence, for that matter every hero is different, we can't compair heros.

this comment i read is a bull****, just like the ediot mediator, saying Gandhiji a politician. and nehru is one of the best heros of independence, so stop all this stupid comments.
 
Old 19-09-2006, 03:46 PM   #18 (permalink)
String Phreak
 
mediator's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: In ur Evil Mind!
Posts: 2,453
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

@Freshseasons........I dont wanna fight either bro. All facts u stated I already know them. About britishers scared of japan it understood that i was talking about pre-atomic bombing! About Gandhiji I didnt meant any offence. But yes he was used!

Tell me urself if u were a britisher interested in greatly in India and there's a group of non-violent people in front of u, who wont even touch u, and ask verbelly to u to leave India. Will u leave India just like that? If there's anyone from the mass who kills ur britisher friend then u'll kill the whole gang of it! But what if the gangs size increases day by day and u feel great sense of insecurity?

How can the britishers leave India just like that? India was called the "Golden bird" in tha past because of greatest reserves of Golds and diamonds found in India! Bitishers had a great interest in India. I'm not imagining things bro. But these kind of facts came across various debates on news channels itself! Why didnt Gandhiji become a leader himself instead of supporting Nehru ji? I didnt mean that he was really a pawn and worked under Britishers. But yes he was being used! And used like a pawn.

Ur right there's no need to fight on this! Its history after all.....the facts might have bent in the due course of time! But I formed mah opinion only after watching debates on various news channels!

Lets come to the main topic!
What do say now? Is satygraha the answer in today's time when no leader feels guilty of his work or feel sorrow after the death of every jawan on the border or after every terrorist attack, when the reservation is implemented inspite of mass stage protests by the students demolishing the meaning of Democracy and notion of equality to all..........list goes on and on?

@digital_fan....the debate just starte and u started making personal comments already? Wait for 5-6 posts bro and then make as many comments as u want. I wont mind that. I think all u did in ur life is reading history books! Ever watched TV debates, that come on various news channels? Not only I but whole lotta people think he was a politician! If u wanna debate....I'll promise u a debate...Just gimme 1 day to gather all my history lessons back! And I'll prove he was indeed a politician though he did some good work to like unifying India!
He did good work for India, unified the masses, but Satygraha was no answer and lotta people were killed because of that! And Nehru the greatest leader? Do u know he got India divided to India pakistan? Dont say it was because of that Jinnah. Nehru cud have boycotted his request and we didnt have to see the Kashmir issue now and terrorism all the way!
Let me tell u I used to think like u only untill I started watching these debates on news channels and listening to historians!

Neways if u wanna debate on this then wait till 24th...actually I'm having exams!
__________________
Bad Bad server.....No candy for u!

Last edited by mediator; 20-09-2006 at 12:05 AM.
mediator is offline  
Old 19-09-2006, 04:05 PM   #19 (permalink)
King of my own Castle
 
freshseasons's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Humor and wit.
Posts: 1,238
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Quote:
Originally Posted by mediator
@Freshseasons........

Tell me urself if u were a britisher interested in greatly in India and there's a group of non-violent people in front of u, who wont even touch u, and ask verbelly to u to leave India. Will u leave India just like that? If there's anyone from the mass who kills ur britisher friend then u'll kill the whole gang of it! But what if the gangs size increases day by day and u feel great sense of insecurity?
I think i would if i were a Britisher ..since the group is not even touching me it will make me think have i gone mad fighting agaisnt people who dont even want to harm me..i will think it over and introspect. Yes i will leave india.
The question of killing my friend by mob wouldnt have happend if Gandhiji was there . But with People like you who love voilence i wouldnt have left india. Infact i would have gathered more troops and armies ..got best of the weapons and given a fit reply.There is no end to revenge. But with Non voilence and peaceful mob it would have made me think where i have gone wrong.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mediator
Why didnt Gandhiji become a leader himself instead of supporting Nehru? I didnt mean that he was really a pawn and worked under Britishers. But yes he was being used! And used like a pawn.
You said Gandhiji was a Politician and now you said why didint he be leader himself. Doesnt this answers you.Coz the reason is Gandhiji was never a Politician so he never wanted any Seat of power related post. He was a humble man who was at peace with self unlike Other Leaders.And Gandhiji never supported Nehru. Infact for Jinha Gandhiji made Nehru sacrifice most of the things. He even proposed that Jinha be the first Prime Minister of India if Pakistan was not formed.This is not manupulation.Its Self sacrifice and love for the Mother nation Gandhiji had...
And dont bother with the History books Mate. All are filled with devotion to Gandhiji.LOL ..Best Luck for the Exams
freshseasons is offline  
Old 19-09-2006, 04:48 PM   #20 (permalink)
String Phreak
 
mediator's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: In ur Evil Mind!
Posts: 2,453
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Quote:
Originally Posted by freshseasons
I think i would if i were a Britisher ..since the group is not even touching me it will make me think have i gone mad fighting agaisnt people who dont even want to harm me..i will think it over and introspect. Yes i will leave india.
Really? What about the the Indian treasure? Will u be interested in Treasure or People? I think u said this bcoz of ur support to GandhiJi!

See man I'm not saying he did nothing! Yea he did unified India, but coming back to topic the satyagraha was no anwer! Unifiying India and Non-violence struggle are 2 different things!

Quote:
Originally Posted by freshseasons
The question of killing my friend by mob wouldnt have happend if Gandhiji was there . But with People like you who love voilence i wouldnt have left india. Infact i would have gathered more troops and armies ..got best of the weapons and given a fit reply.There is no end to revenge. But with Non voilence and peaceful mob it would have made me think where i have gone wrong.
Ur getting emotional man! U see I'm talking peacefully right now. I'm not violent at all. But tell me what did India achieve by friendship with Pakisan? AB Vajpayee went to Pakistan to make friends with them and we saw KArgil...list is endless! I'm not saying we shud attack pakistan then! We dont need to. I can talk about why so!

Quote:
Originally Posted by freshseasons
You said Gandhiji was a Politician and now you said why didint he be leader himself. Doesnt this answers you
Dis is what I'm saying. Did u ever tried to find out why he didnt become a leader himself? He was a politician but not like our modern politicians. God If he were like that then ofcors he wud have become the Indian leader in first place! And gandhiji wasnt killed by britisher also! Do u know who killed Gandhiji?

And for rest of history. I know that! Guess u all are very emotionally attached to gandhiji! So lets call it off. No further arguments about Gandhiji! I also do respect him coz he really unified India and woke them up, did a lot of daring things. But if u read his history and read what historians have to say then I guess I wont have to continue here for 12-13 pages of this thread and u wont be making any personal comments here then.

Most of u only have read he was a hero, I'm not saying he was not! But....Oh forget it! Lets stop talking about him and destroying his soul's peace!

So lets talk about Satyagraha in modern time and let me study for exams guys!
I believe Satyagraha works when there is a misunderstanding and the enemy doesn't have any motive. But for Pakistan,politicans they have motive and Britshers also did. For Pakistan its Kashmir/revenge, politicians its votes, Britshers it was more than that! Do u think Satyagraha will really work against them?
__________________
Bad Bad server.....No candy for u!

Last edited by mediator; 19-09-2006 at 05:12 PM.
mediator is offline  
Old 19-09-2006, 06:09 PM   #21 (permalink)
King of my own Castle
 
freshseasons's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Humor and wit.
Posts: 1,238
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

He he ,This is turning out to be one of those posts where " i post the Last wins". I had rather have things depend on logic and reason.Coz Debates are not like Chess Game where both the opponents start on the same note and pieces and who ever is intelligent wins.Debates require Truth and sustenance for that. Even the weaker ones win over, if his conclusion is true . Which brings us to one thing......i hate to start over again...
I still cannot believe i m here in flesh and Blood typing my guts out talking to the person who is also in flesh and blood presumly and must also be breathing.....whom some lazy teacher from his school forgot to tell him," GANDHIJI WAS NOT A POLITICIAN." How on this earth where everything is so workable you came to this silly conclusion.Seriously i hate your teacher.
Anyways i believe you wont end this so soon as must definatly get the time off your studying breaks and thats all it takes to type here..Login and type ones guts out...hha ha ha ..
freshseasons is offline  
Old 19-09-2006, 08:40 PM   #22 (permalink)
String Phreak
 
mediator's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: In ur Evil Mind!
Posts: 2,453
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

@freshseasons......."I post the last wins?" . Not yet Buddy! Enjoying ma absence as ur win? Huh dood? Ur mistaken! I guess u hate me huh? Thats why u dont want me to study for exams!
Neways the topic of teacher telling me something is irrelevant coz I was too taughtt that he was he hero and all. Yes he was! But ya I say it again he was a politician. Can u name any elected leader atleast Indian who is not a politician in real sense?

Hey man u urself wanted to end the topic on Gandhiji. Now ur provoking me urself? I was starting to gear up, but soon realised that something are better not be talked about. Yes I can continue this thread like my other threads. Want to do that? I hope not!

Now can u stick to the topic of this thread? or wanna deviate it to "Gandhiji politician or not"?

I saw this post of urs and I thought u must have replied to some of mah Non-Gandhiji points as u and nobody here wanna talk on that(Gandhiji issue). But the only thing I saw is u being overwhelmed with joy because I restrained mahself from talking about his politics!
Well bro backing out from an example because of emotions attached to it is not called "Quit or defeat" but rather called "Sensibility" and then provoking that sensible guy after restraining him on such a topic and thinking of false victory is called "Stupidity".
U may have noticed in the "Vande mataram thread" that I cud have spoken like hell like I always do.......but I adviced others too not to talk about something with which the emotions of so many Indians is attached with and I made just one point!

Seems u were sooooo overjoyed, but only did what u told " Not to talk about Gandhiji"? Did I do somethng wrong by not saying anything further about him?

Neways the next time any Tv debate on this topic about Gandhiji comes, then please watch it carefully! It will really lower the false sense of happiness ur experiencing.

By the way I wrote about Satygraha and u as a Britisher! Where is the reply?
__________________
Bad Bad server.....No candy for u!

Last edited by mediator; 19-09-2006 at 11:43 PM.
mediator is offline  
Old 20-09-2006, 01:38 PM   #23 (permalink)
King of my own Castle
 
freshseasons's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Humor and wit.
Posts: 1,238
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Quote:
Originally Posted by mediator
I guess u hate me huh? Thats why u dont want me to study for exams!
Really i dont hate you ! There no partiality. I hate everybody equally. Study for the exams mate..And still whats the point if few nuts on planet feel Gandhiji is a politician. I can't fight all eh! So waste of efforts there.But i didint get that one sentence you said . Gandhiji is a politician in other way.
I dont understand these sentences.
If one Writes" Do the Girl," it Preciously means just that.Not like, ok what i meant was do the girls hair or do her house work. So if you said Gandhiji was a politician he was for you in all the way.
He he ..i will leave you .dont waste time ..concentrate on exams.May be there you will give reaally good answers! Peace Mate.
freshseasons is offline  
Old 20-09-2006, 02:38 PM   #24 (permalink)
String Phreak
 
mediator's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: In ur Evil Mind!
Posts: 2,453
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Quote:
Originally Posted by freshseasons
He he ..i will leave you
Really?....Attitude eh? U dont like peace treaty..do u? Guess ur feeling really high coz I'm not speaking on such topic with which emotions of so many of my brothers,Indians are attached. Neways I really pity people like u who cant speak on real topics like Satyagraha and others and then feel high when nobody else is speaking on some emotionfull/sensitive topic like "Gandiji's one"!

Quote:
Originally Posted by freshseasons
And still whats the point if few nuts on planet feel Gandhiji is a politician.
YEa thats history now......But similarly I pity the few freaks who dunno the history in detail, dont watch TV debates on such topics and only say what they are taught in classrooms! Its like u know a maths formula and u memorise it, use it extensively but never cared to find how it was derived actually and who derived it!
Never mind most people like u suffer from ignorance on such topic! Its Ok!

So...... are u out of ur false sense of happiness or hauliicinating victory or whateva u might be imagining?? Can we proceed if ur done celebrating ur dream? Are u done boasting about ur arrogance and ignorance? CAn we move on?

Where is the reply on Satygraha and u as britisher? This is the second time I'm asking! Oh forget the exams now....guess I was going soft on u! So do u have the guts to proceed on the topic of this thread? Or u'll boast pathetically in ur next post toooo?

I expect a good loooong post from u now that can entertain me! Lets start!

EPEACE!
__________________
Bad Bad server.....No candy for u!

Last edited by mediator; 20-09-2006 at 03:05 PM.
mediator is offline  
Old 20-09-2006, 04:43 PM   #25 (permalink)
digit_fan
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Thumbs down Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Quote:
Originally Posted by mediator
Neways if u wanna debate on this then wait till 24th...actually I'm having exams!
honestly i don't go to sites that has less traffic than my own site, but digit pulls that's why am here.

then i read such posts like gandhiji is a politician, if he was, he would have been our prime minister, but's he was not.

anyways, read and learn, and this time don't fail in your exam, though this is a nice way to chicken out from the debate, that too after saying gandhiji as a politician.

repeating the previous statement to remove any confusion, real leader, bhagat singh, subhas chandra bose, and all the people who faught for freedom, all are real heros, and yes including all of those as well who did satyagraha, like gandhiji. don't compair our leaders, all are real leaders, learn to respect them.


saying gandhiji a politician when gandhi jayanti is so near, mediator shame on you, you are not good enough to be an indian.

i don't want to make personal comments, but if you don't apologise clearly for your shameful act, you will be considered as a traitor of india.

real leaders, what do you think gandhiji is not a real leader, he is false, unreal, i said you have lost your mind, i was wrong, you can't have a mind!
 
Old 20-09-2006, 05:18 PM   #26 (permalink)
String Phreak
 
mediator's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: In ur Evil Mind!
Posts: 2,453
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

Quote:
Originally Posted by digital_fan
honestly i don't go to sites that has less traffic than my own site, but digit pulls that's why am here.
Ya like u did a big deed! "Ehsaan kar diya yahan aa ke?"


@digital_fan.......U talk big! I see ur new to the forums huh? But lemme tell u if dont know Indian history well, then u dont have any right to call urself Indian either! I know what I am talking! And chicken out..? Palllleeease! Did I chicken out from this thread and its topic....... boy? Huh others who must be reading mah posts in several debates must be laughing at u right now!

In a debate "China Vs India" if someone says India is better than Pakistan, then do u start fighting on "India Vs Pakistan" debate??

I said he was a politician, I didnt say he was a villain! How do u define a politician?? Please tell me ur definition first and then I'll clear any of ur doubts! I see the only picture of a politician in ur mind is todays politicians like laloo! Boy this is the 21st century....we have sevaral political parties. Time's not the same as it used to be 50 or 60 yrs ago when congress was the sole majority party!

So do u wanna fight on the topic of the thread? or just wanna drop in by occasionally and make personal comments like a stereotypical,uninterested leftist,cpm debater who only speaks whenever he finds the atmosphere appropriate for him?

So how do u find gandhiji's satyagraha effective against Britishers? If u have the GUTS then talk on this. Or open another thread "Gandhiji a politician or not!"!
Neways neither u replied to Nehru's statement I gave nor u replied about the various satyagraha posts I gave! What are u trying to prove kid?

Do u express ur agony in ur classrooms too whenever u find something is not right according to u?
If u wanna abuse then be my guest, abuse in Hindi that will be more lively! But please talk on the current topic!
U behave like @freshseasons now.......doing all the blablabla instead of making relevant points on the topic of this thread!
__________________
Bad Bad server.....No candy for u!

Last edited by mediator; 20-09-2006 at 05:23 PM.
mediator is offline  
Old 20-09-2006, 05:36 PM   #27 (permalink)
The Lord of Death
 
Yamaraj's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: यमलोक
Posts: 253
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

@freshseasons & digit_fan:
Get rid of your annoying and stupid ignorance. Do you even know what the
word "politician" stands for? No wonder, you all have been reciting what was
taught in the classes and mentioned in stupid text books.

Gandhi was a politician. He was also responsible for some of the dirty politics
in Congress party, easily comparable to the deeds of modern ******* politicians.
It's no big secret that he favored Nehru over Bose, and even forced Bose to
resign, who was President of the Congress at the time. He coerced other party
members to resign in favor of Nehru & himself, and against Bose so he could be
held responsible for the mass resignations.

Gandhi also provided "moral support" to the British in WWII, even against the
will of most of the Congress party members. He even urged Indian youth to
join British forces to fight for the "Queen".

His methods of truth and non-violence weren't unknown to the mankind, as
Buddha and Christ practised the same well ahead before him. He was merely
following the teachings and preachings of other leaders. But I do respect him
for that. I also like the fact that he remained vegetarian for the rest of his life.

I also accuse him of being overly selfish, and not taking enough care of his wife
and children. He also admired the British superiority over others. Remember,
alternate history is usually ignored by the coming generations, and what remains
is a vague representation of the personna - good or evil.

Overall, I like Gandhi as a person. He achieved some great things, but he had
his share of failings and bad deeds, like any other common man. As a great
leader of our Nation or Rashtrapita, I think he falls a little short of it.

Last edited by Yamaraj; 20-09-2006 at 05:44 PM.
Yamaraj is offline  
Old 20-09-2006, 06:44 PM   #28 (permalink)
Apprentice
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 62
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

This discussion is going over the line, i think. And mediator, don't call me as someone looking for an opportunity to stick their nose up bcoz my xams just ended. Well, i am not with any one of u guyz. I started this thread to discuss whether raw force works against terrorists or "satyagraha". And i didn't start this thread to discuss how good Gandhiji was as a politician.
Have a debate about THE topic, not "around" the topic.
freakanomics is offline  
Old 20-09-2006, 07:02 PM   #29 (permalink)
String Phreak
 
mediator's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: In ur Evil Mind!
Posts: 2,453
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

@freakanomics......Chillll man! When did I quoted u in mah posts? Till now I only replied to @freshreasons and @digital_fan! I never said anything against u or ur posts!

Quote:
Originally Posted by freakanomics
And mediator, don't call me as someone looking for an opportunity to stick their nose up bcoz my xams just ended.
For the opportunity stuff I said this about @digital_fan. Or are u the same person with different alias??

Neways @digital_fan and @freshreasons.........I guess u wont like what @yamaraja has said! But thats the truth. But thats not the complete truth! Thats why I said to watch TV debates, listen to historians instead of blabbering out what ur history teacher told u or u read in history books!
Its all history! So lets not talk about it...... Ok? Let the "Gandhiji Politican?" debate end here like "Vande mataram" one did or if u still wanna get enlightened then open another thread!

So please talk about satyagraha and what all I asked u in my previous posts!
__________________
Bad Bad server.....No candy for u!
mediator is offline  
Old 22-09-2006, 01:23 AM   #30 (permalink)
String Phreak
 
mediator's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: In ur Evil Mind!
Posts: 2,453
Default Re: Can the war against terrorists be won by Satyagraha???

@digital_fan , @freshreasons.....say something kids! Whole more than 1 day has passed and I see from the status that u come 3-4 times in the forums!
When I wasnt speaking properly due to exams and going easy on u.....u were boasting...and @freshreasons making comments like "I post the last win" and "I leave u". What a joke!!
Its not even 6-7 pages of this thread and @freshreasons making pathetic comments like that!

Now forget the exams and when I just began gearing up, u chickened out? Why do u guys step in a thread in which u dont have guts to continue? Oh palllleeease entertain me! I expected a good debate from u! where are u guys....I'm missing u!!
__________________
Bad Bad server.....No candy for u!

Last edited by mediator; 22-09-2006 at 02:24 AM.
mediator is offline  
Closed Thread

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 03:15 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.

Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.3.2