Caught speaking Malayalam, Apollo nurses asked to resign

[dips_view]

The incident(Want Resignation for speaking in native language) isthe clear violation of human rights..Its also gags our constitution.
I really don't understand How some People Support/Justified it?

originally posted by NecleusKore
^+1
If it's in the contract, IT'S IN THE CONTRACT

Hey, Do u support bondage labor??????

[i_am_crack]

There is s diff between bondage labour and signed contract... You can get out with bondage labour but not easy in signed contract.. cause its supported by/as per labour law. Want to know who i am ... As u r HR Dept

eBRo

[Ramakrishnan]

Originally Posted by hailgautam

They were speaking in private and it is intrusion into private lives by Apollo if the Nursing Superintendent overhears them greet each other. Contracts or agreements can not over-ride fundamental rights. Being Indian it is our fundamental right to speak any language we wish and can speak. As long as it is not hampering the work and in this case lives of other people can not be a case for dismissal – I can’t see how greeting each other jeopardises other’s lives.

I also agree with you.

[Rahim]

We just need mediator & karnivore in this thread and rest assure this thread will have a long life

I dont agree with NucleusKore & MHG. Dont you have any heart? especially you Neville bro since you are in that profession

In any case, speaking in native languages might jeopardise patient safety

Can some guy throw some light on the safety BS
Next is what: One must use fork and spoon & not her hand to eat her rice and dal since Englishmen do so? Lame rules and disgusting for those supporting it.

[Baker]

^^

completely agreed

[MetalheadGautham]

Thread moved to Fight Club since its being converted to an open debate.
Have fun...........
...................
.............
.........
......Till I reply later

[appserver]

Originally Posted by MetalheadGautham

What do you mean "biased" ? Its a place for a certain type of people. Others are welcome only if they agree to be like the type of people its designed for.

Biased,I mean if the hospital superintendent, Usha Banerjee finds that her employee talks in Hindi or in Usha's mother tongue, instead of any other regional languages, then she should take similar action. Plain and simple!

Again I am repeating, we should completely oblige the rules and regulations of an organization. But accident or unfortunate mistakes should not punished to this extreme.

[MetalheadGautham]

Originally Posted by appserver

Biased,I mean if the hospital superintendent, Usha Banerjee finds that her employee talks in Hindi or in Usha's mother tongue, instead of any other regional languages, then she should take similar action. Plain and simple!

Again I am repeating, we should completely oblige the rules and regulations of an organization. But accident or unfortunate mistakes should not punished to this extreme.

Yes that should happen. But unfortunately, it does not because of mismanagement.

[dips_view]

why don't u understand its its clear violation of civil liberty in the name of contract/management??
and also against our constitution...
Before 1947(!!??) WE were bound by British rules/contract/management.or we still bound to it??

[Faun]

Originally Posted by dips_view

why don't u understand its its clear violation of civil liberty in the name of contract/management??
and also against our constitution...
Before 1947(!!??) WE were bound by British rules/contract/management.or we still bound to it??

What is our constitution ?

[dips_view]

posted by ichi..
What is our constitution ?

Any section of the citizens residing in the territory of India or any part there of having a distinct language, script or culture of its own shall have the right to conserve the same.

if u still don't understand that.. then borrow a book from 5-10th grade student and read that..

[Faun]

Originally Posted by dips_view

Any section of the citizens residing in the territory of India or any part there of having a distinct language, script or culture of its own shall have the right to conserve the same.

if u still don't understand that.. then borrow a book from 5-10th grade student and read that..

However there are exceptions, Its you who need to borrow a book.

Privacy of voters is another thing but if you choose not to vote then your identity must be revealed. Which in my opinion is quite opposite to the basic right of privacy in voting.

India's constitution is a patch up work. There is no true freedom of press too.

A state can regulate these rights as and when required. Private firms on contract are not bound to these rights.

Indian constitution is pseudo-secular. There is no uniform civil code (we can only dream of that).

[j1n M@tt]

^^ +1

[dips_view]

To ichi,
u r supporting violation civil liberties in the name of contract/management.in the other hand u demand uniform civil code,freedom of press.
Man first make up ur mind.

[Rahim]

^ichi needs english subtitles

[MetalheadGautham]

Originally Posted by dips_view

To ichi,
u r supporting violation civil liberties in the name of contract/management.in the other hand u demand uniform civil code,freedom of press.
Man first make up ur mind.

WTF ? You say contracted labour where somebody states that they are willing to work under certain terms and conditions is violation of civil liberties but don't agree that Uniforms in schools are also violations of civil liberties ?

[nix]

i agree with metalheadgautam.

I support english as the national language of this country, this removes any room for conflict as to which language should be the national language.

if you make tamil the national language, lot of ppl will cry foul. Lot of people also don't like the fact that hindi is the national language.

The problem is that our leaders made states on regional lines. that was a blunder.

@appserver: some people prefer to speak in english not "for fashion", but because it gives you confidence. confidence for life. People who have good control over engish are sought after all over india, thats how it is, weather you like it or not.

and dont compare india with germany. germany doesnt have a 100 languages, so they have no problems choosing a national language. they also have windows and all softwares made in their language. But we cant do that. we cannot have a made-for-india -100-language-pack windows.

[Liverpool_fan]

Originally Posted by nix

and dont compare india with germany. germany doesnt have a 100 languages, so they have no problems choosing a national language. they also have windows and all softwares made in their language. But we cant do that. we cannot have a made-for-india -100-language-pack windows.

LOL! Windows!
Ya! Indian political leaders embrace Linux and get a 100-language-pack OS.

[thul]

Originally Posted by Liverpool_fan

LOL! Windows!
Ya! Indian political leaders embrace Linux and get a 100-language-pack OS.

One problem solved still many problems left due to multiculturalism and regions demarcated specifically for that.