Calling All Harry Potter Fans!!

[fun2sh]

HI GUYS!!! now less than 2 months r left before the final book comes in our hand. so lets start a new discussion ON WAT WILL HAPPEN IN BOOK 7. great though i cant wait for the book to come

[caje143]

Hey fun2sh,

just popped in to say a hi

well i too am a harry potter fan dude.. but not very much... i have watched just 4 parts of the movie and neva read any of the books..

so whats this 7th Book got?? whats it about?

[fun2sh]

Originally Posted by caje143

Hey fun2sh,

just popped in to say a hi

well i too am a harry potter fan dude.. but not very much... i have watched just 4 parts of the movie and neva read any of the books..

so whats this 7th Book got?? whats it about?

WAT U NEVER READ ANY OF THE BOOKS THEN ALSO U R "FAN GREAT" . I DONT KHOW WAT WILL U BECOME AFTER READIN THE BOOKS

[caje143]

Originally Posted by fun2sh

WAT U NEVER READ ANY OF THE BOOKS THEN ALSO U R "FAN GREAT" . I DONT KHOW WAT WILL U BECOME AFTER READIN THE BOOKS

Well i enjoy the Movies alot... dunoo if i get time will get some books and start reading....

[ashnik]

well, movies don't cover the whole book, also some manipulations r done to.
Harry Potter movies take too much of cinematic liberty...
I didn't like the movies....
LOTR series is well covered in movies. good example..

[champ_rock]

Dumbledore will definately come back and Snape will turn out to be loyal to the Order in the end

can somebody link me wid a site thts selling HP7 for cheapest...
i heard indiaplaza was allowing pre-bookings at rs630 a month ago in some offer. now d rates arnd rs 1000

[sumeet singh]

yeah.. u can get HP7 the cheapest from firstandsecond.com
Try that
the best book selling site.... wat i think

I've read all the six books and watched all the four movies. The movies were good but only for those who haven't read the books. The Goblet of Fire book and movie seemed like two different things with most of the content of the book either missing or modified. For e.g. in the book Dobby have harry the gillyweed that made him breathe underwater but in the movie they showed Neville giving it to Harry.

[fun2sh]

Originally Posted by champ_rock

Dumbledore will definately come back and Snape will turn out to be loyal to the Order in the end

wel dumbledore is dead though he is in the book 7 in some form. its confirmed by Jo also

[ssk_the_gr8]

Originally Posted by krazyfrog

I've read all the six books and watched all the four movies. The movies were good but only for those who haven't read the books. The Goblet of Fire book and movie seemed like two different things with most of the content of the book either missing or modified. For e.g. in the book Dobby have harry the gillyweed that made him breathe underwater but in the movie they showed Neville giving it to Harry.

upto the 3rd book it was possible to make movies..cuz they were thin but from goblet of fire the books r 500 pages + so if they have to make a good movie with complete detail they will have to make a 6 hour movie

[ashisharya]

watched all da mov n books also

[Pratyush]

Dumbledore is dead and he will definitely not return. Regarding Snape, he isn't evil

it may be possible that dumbledore told snape to finish him off and let harry face vol- (flinch) err you-know-who alone. snape has done many things for the order. so, telling he's evil is a bad joke.

just visit any of the potter fansites, and u will know evrything.

[fun2sh]

Originally Posted by Pratyush

Dumbledore is dead and he will definitely not return. Regarding Snape, he isn't evil

it may be possible that dumbledore told snape to finish him off and let harry face vol- (flinch) err you-know-who alone. snape has done many things for the order. so, telling he's evil is a bad joke.

just visit any of the potter fansites, and u will know evrything.

dumbledore is back in some form. its confirmed go here n see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_P...eathly_Hallows

Rowling clarified that "Dumbledore is definitely dead", when asked by Salman Rushdie and others at Radio City Music Hall in New York City. Rowling answered the same question three times, each time with increasing conviction.[51] However, on the set of the Order of the Phoenix film, she remarked; "Dumbledore's giving me a lot of trouble". When asked "But isn't he dead?" by Daniel Radcliffe, she explained; "Well, yeah, but it's more complex ...."

[Quiz_Master]

WOW a potter thread. I haven't noticed it.

If its about who is a Big Potter fan, then let me tell you. The name of that person is

QUIZ_MASTER.

I have readed all the books. Each book more then 20 times.[ I rember every quote now.]
Watched every movie. (Countless times)
Played every game (all 5 games to be specific.).

_________

I am also on COS forums by name Quiz_Master,
anyone from here Visit that forum?
I have written many HP theories there. and made many hypotheses there.
___________

Some spoiler for you

RAB is Regulus Augustus Black. (But everyone knows this. )
Dumbledore is REALLY dead. (Weknow this allready too. )
Snape is not evil. (Now this can be discussed. )
_)_____
Book 7 will going to realese in 39 Days 10 hours. Lets see what happens.

[sachin_kothari]

i have a feeling (and i hate it and hope i am wrong) that Harry Potter will die in the end.
the other character to die could be anyone close to harry and will die early in the book. so both ron and hermionie survive.

[pritish_kul2]

hagrid will die i think so

[esumitkumar]

Im a big fan of HP..is Harry potter the last horcrux ?

[fun2sh]

harry is not a HORCRUX. its also confirmed by Jo.

[esumitkumar]

then how will Hari die (Hari Puttar )

[fun2sh]

why do u want to kill harry. n if he is not a HORCRUX then does it mean that he cant die?

[sachin_kothari]

^^ if u r a regular visitior to any of the harry potter forums or communities, u will understand that harry is not a horcrux and why he will die.

[Quiz_Master]

Well he won't die. It will defeat the purpose of good winning over Evil.
If harry dies then it will mean that there is no good in doing good.

But if he chooses death for himself after defeating Voldy. Well in that case....
NO COMMENTS.

[sachin_kothari]

Originally Posted by Quiz_Master

Well he won't die. It will defeat the purpose of good winning over Evil.
If harry dies then it will mean that there is no good in doing good.

But if he chooses death for himself after defeating Voldy. Well in that case....
NO COMMENTS.

This case will arise (probably never) only if he loses everyone close to him. Why would else he choose death.

As for the purpose of good winning over evil is concerned it has nothing to do with harry dying. dumby once told in the 6th book that there is something more worse than death. its related to something with the door in the ministry which they could not open. so what matters is voldemort's fall not harry's life.

[QwertyManiac]

I like Harry Potter books .. I hate the fans.

Now .. wasn't there a big thread already?

[Quiz_Master]

^^ Why hate fans?
Its the FAN base who made something great. If its because not of fans you probably never have heard of books. Cause fans made these books famous. Else there are 100s of books like potter. But they are not recognised just because no large fan base.
Fans are everything. Be a writer and you will know the importance of FANs.

[fun2sh]

Originally Posted by Quiz_Master

^^ Why hate fans?
Its the FAN base who made something great. If its because not of fans you probably never have heard of books. Cause fans made these books famous. Else there are 100s of books like potter. But they are not recognised just because no large fan base.
Fans are everything. Be a writer and you will know the importance of FANs.

YEAH quite right thing. i started readin harry potter books since 16th aug 2005(that was my birthday then ) n i would hav not started readin it unless all mine hostel friends would hav not been discussin abt harry potter day n night in front of me n forced me too read it too. now i a mad fan of harry. even greater than those of mine friends who forced me too read it.

[Pratyush]

yeah, it's us who have made harry potter famous. every new hp book sells more than the previous one in the series. this really shows that it all depends on us fans.

J.K. Rowling shud start thinking of paying all her fans for making hp successful.he..he..he

[QwertyManiac]

Originally Posted by Quiz_Master

^^ Why hate fans?
Its the FAN base who made something great. If its because not of fans you probably never have heard of books. Cause fans made these books famous. Else there are 100s of books like potter. But they are not recognised just because no large fan base.
Fans are everything. Be a writer and you will know the importance of FANs.

I don't hate fans in general. I hate Harry Potter fans. They go gaga over forgetting a name .. and the hype? Don't ask ..

Just read some better trilogies like Bartimaeus or Inheritance to know just how bad HP is .. But its not bad that JK's still writing it for kids, just saying she should make the book as per her character's age or near it.

You fans just talk facts of the book and keep spilling theories and etc, never look at the writing or language, most of the fans anyway. And to make your post correct, there aren't 100s of books like HP, there are 100s of books better than HP.

I just don't know why some people just get stuck to one read alone. It might be the movie attention perhaps.

I'd rather like good criticism than a kiddish fan base promoting my writings. Fans should be of the author, not the book, get that right.

[faraaz]

Harry is definitely going to die...because JK Rowling has confirmed only 7 books and confirmed furthermore, that NO more HP books after book 7! And have you seen the rabid fans out there? They're not going to leave her alone. QED...she kills Harry, no more harassment. Furthermore, after she's finished, the publishers can't sell the rights and stuff to have a third party write HP stories, like it happened with Tolkien's things...his son wrote a continuation to some story of his IIRC...its selling in bookstores right now.

So yeah, its not a story based reason, but real life one...HP is gonna die!!