1.Medal of Honor-Allied Assault ( for its immersive nature,great sounds-those days were just like being in war)
2.Max Payne ( 1 & 2) (I think no other game can beat it in style and voice acting particularly that of Payne himself-Eventhough it was short,the content was great)
3.Half life ( My first games, so still love it. Very long.Absolutely great story except the Alien levels and the climax)
4.Mafia ( I thought Mafia was one of the most underrated games of our time.It had great long story,beautiful graphics, great sounds)
5.Return to Castle Wolfenstein (It had great story,beautiful graphics, great sounds with some of the best Enemies.Nice twists too.)
Eventhough I like GTA 3 for its open endedness I just think it was somewhat hyped.But I still play it and I am with 84% completion)
Games I think I'll play soon
1.Call of Duty(Going by reviews is going to be 10 times better than MOH series.Some sites have described it as the best FPS of all time.Created by people who created Medal of Honor.They jus walked away from EA games to create a new company Infinity Ward)
2.GTA 3 Vice City
3.Silent hill
4.Halo
5.Medal of Honor-Rising Sun
try visiting
http://www.thinkdigit.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=293 too